The Blog

OmniFocus, our work in progress

by Linda Sharps on September 25, 2006

We just got an email from our esteemed pal Wrong Size Glass, who wrote:

Hey Gals & Guys,

I was just wondering what ever happened to the search for a good 'code name' for the Omni â??GTD appâ???

Well, WSG, therein lies a tale! Yes indeed, a long and convoluted tale with mighty dragons and heroic journeys and a scrappy little dog and â??

You know what, never mind all that. I'll just cut to the chase and tell you the name we've decided on, for now at least, is OmniFocus. I see that commenter Cameron suggested that very same name just two days ago in response to this entry, so I will take that as a Positive Sign that “OmniFocus” is an okay name.

(Especially since no one liked my idea: OmniFu. What? It's a perfectly cromulent word.)

OmniQuest was a big contender, although some of us felt it was a little too gamey. Not in the sense that it smelled weird, but…oh, you know, the dragons and heroic journeys and so on.

So: OmniFocus. It has a name. It has a team of engineers working on it, a user interface guru mocking up modes and widgets for it, and a product manager whose Herculean job it is to herd this whole mess towards an elusive ship date.

Now for your participation! Many of you have already sent us some really, really useful feedback on what you're looking for in this type of personal organization application. What we wanted to ask this time is, what are you currently using for this purpose? Index cards? Kinkless and OmniOutliner? Other apps/other analog methods?

If you wouldn't mind sharing, we'd love to know. Hit us up in the comments section or by email.

 

Comments

I'm currently implementing GTD using Kinkless and OmniOutliner Pro w/ iCal sync enabled.


Without the iCal sync, I would probably not be using this combination, as I'm on the road quite a bit, and need to have easy access to my action lists (I sync with my Treo 650). So I'm hoping OmniFocus integrates well with iCal and syncs like Kinkless currently does.

jacob

09.25.06 10:00 AM

Though 'OmniFocus' sounds pretty good, I'm voting for 'OmniFu' as soon as I get my Deibold Voting Machine to boot Linux.

WrongSizeGlass

09.25.06 10:08 AM

I don't follow the GTD system really strictly, because I don't have that many tasks. So a complete GTD system would be a bit of an overkill.

I use index cards to write down tasks I need to do today/this week. I use iCal for simple recurring tasks (ie get a haircut every 2 months) and let it notify me through e-mail.

Jan

09.25.06 10:11 AM

I agree - the need to sync with iCal for tasks is important. I would like to see something a little more elegant than a calendar for each context though. And a little more detail in the sync would be nice (kGTD does not reference the project in the iCal task, so multiple projects with similar tasks can be a problem). Obviously, compatibility with OmniPlan/OmniOutliner is key. Since iCal doesn't support Growl elegantly I would like to see an optional agent that can run in the background and give growl notifications (coupled with an ability to NOT sync alarms to iCal).

Chris

09.25.06 10:15 AM

I can't believe I missed a Simpson's reference! Yes, Linda, it is a perfectly cromulent word.

WrongSizeGlass

09.25.06 10:22 AM

I am really looking forward to an Omni GTD app. I’m currently implementing GTD using Kinkless and OmniOutliner Pro with iCal sync . I works fine, but not well enough. As much as I prefer to work on my Mac all the time, my problem is that I can't use my Mac while I am at work and sometimes when I am on the road. My key demand for a GTD app is “ubiquitiousness”. Create an app, which I can use on the web and on my Mac (and maybe with a mobile device) and it would really establish a new standard in GTD productivity. I imagine that's a huge challenge but this would really be a unique feature!

Wolf-Christian

09.25.06 10:23 AM

I'm currently using EasyTask Manager.


http://www.orionbelt.com/

Trevor

09.25.06 10:34 AM

Using Kinkless; so long as OmniFocus (great name!) has similar functionality, and you take care to sync with PDAs (Palm for me), it's going to be a terrific system. Good luck!

John

09.25.06 10:43 AM

I use kGTD/OO. I have but one feature request for OmniFocus: pleasepleaseplease make it scriptable. Very, very scriptable.

dansays

09.25.06 10:53 AM

I'm currently using kGTD/OO. Is there any chance of being able to import the tasks from our current kGTD/OO files? I'm sold if that's the case!

Jeremy Higgs

09.25.06 11:03 AM

omnioutliner + kgtd is what i use right now, but it's not perfect.

d

09.25.06 11:26 AM

Kinkless + OOP

Rishabh

09.25.06 11:29 AM

Was using OOP&kGTD; switched to Tracks a few months ago as it felt less jerry-rigged, and seemed to have responsive developers and interesting plans. It works well for me.

Craig

09.25.06 11:35 AM

Index cards all the way BABY! There like so fats and slick, I us eth blank sides of them :D Lets you draw and detail ideas without the useless lines.

tripdragon

09.25.06 11:46 AM

I thought maybe you were stealing the idea from my free ideas list: http://www.red-sweater.com/blog/192/ten-free-ideas (search for focus)


but I'm happily looking forward to the GTD app, too :)

Daniel Jalkut

09.25.06 12:16 PM

I'm currently maintaining Projects and Next Actions lists in iCal, which works reasonably well for a simple set of lists. But it slows down at high volume. Syncing to Palm (absolute necessity for me!). Also using .Mac syncing, so I can add to and review my lists from any of my Macs. Using OmniOutliner to develop project plans.

Paul Patanella

09.25.06 12:58 PM

Currently using Kinkless + OO. I'd love to be able to import my list from the current system! I also like being able to see my To-dos chronologically and categorically in iCal using calendar groups (as suggested by 43folders), but I don't actually use iCal's calendaring functionality so that's a bit of wasted system resources. I'd love to see that kind of thing built into the program.

Yinjie

09.25.06 1:23 PM

Used index cards for years.  Just switched to Kinkless with OOP.  iCal integration does not work well…. iCal is hosed—please do right.  Also… kinkless does not sort by due date—problematic.  Would completely love to have to do's replicate to my blackberry to do's via PMBlackberry.  That would be fantastic.  Looking very forward to your app.  Please get it out in beta soon!

jimvas

09.25.06 1:34 PM

Also using OO + Kinkless. I agree with the crowd, good iSync support is a must – I using iSync daily to synchronize with iCal and my mobile phone.

One particular request would be better support for referencing external stuff: files (to act upon), url (forms to fill out for instance). One idea to explore would be to use Growl for notifications.

Matthias Wiesmann

09.25.06 1:36 PM

Very excited for this.  I will have to send a list of hopes and dreams by email.  But I'm a member of the addicted kGTD club.  It's a love/hate relationship, and I have high hopes for OmniFocus (also love the name).  Thanks for this, good luck!  Can't wait to hear more.

Will Koffel

09.25.06 2:04 PM

From the look of things, the first thing you should do is simply hire the guy who made Kinkless.


iCal, GCal support a plus.  Bonus points if you can sync contacts with address book.

E Grotz

09.25.06 2:12 PM

Like many others have stated here I use kGTD and OO with syncing to iCal and my Palm. I'm interested in http://www.midnightbeep.com and their Inbox. It looks wonderful but, since its early beta, I haven't really been able to try out all the features. I'm really looking forward to what you at Omnigroup can come up with as an amazing GTD app!

Jim Kreft

09.25.06 2:13 PM

Currently I'm using DayLite. Powerful, but unwieldly.

Frank Bruno

09.25.06 2:18 PM

If you want to hit a homerun, create a companion Palm OS app that syncs with OmniFocus. Also, it should have the ability to sync with Google calendar and iCal.

HonorGuy7

09.25.06 2:19 PM

I use Kinkless GTD along with scripts to export it to my iPod and exporting it to my website (for viewing anywhere that there's a 'net connection).


I have a strong need to share a file between work and home as well. Currently I fake this through iCal sync so I subscribe to my home calendars at work and vise-versa, so I'm never far from a read-only list of my tasks. Something a bit syncier would be better, tho.


I also INPUT data through mail (custom rules create KGTD tasks so I can send tasks from my cell phone), voice memos and my Clie N710 (old but still kickin').


So I hope OmniFocus has big support for Applescript (I assume it will, as an Omni app) and that it also can sync in some fashion with other computers and/or iCal.


I'm excited you're working on this! I can't wait to see what you come up with! I urge you to remember one thing as you try to do GTDness: All that's different about GTD from other task managers is that tasks are organized on two axes (projects and context), instead of one (category/calendar). Other than that, it's a task manager, plain and simple.

Nik

09.25.06 2:25 PM

I use tiddlywiki d^3, and have started to use tiddlyspot for sharing.


some good offline integration to blackberry or exchange (sorry!) is essential

bfp

09.25.06 2:42 PM

Currently using OOP+kGTD. being able to sync info to a palm is essential for me to get stuff done while away from the computer. Hopefully there will be a way to sidestep Missing Sync's inability to update the times that the status of a to-do list item was changed. it sucks having to go through and manually toggle off ->on the ical to-do items that I checked on the palm.


I'm so looking forward to this app. it can't come soon enough.

--matthew

09.25.06 2:58 PM

I'm using kGTD and OmniOutlinerPro. I only bought OOP so I could run kGTD, so you Omni guys owe the kinkless huge thanks. It would be great if you would just place all the GTD stuff into the next version of OutlinerPro; it seems to work pretty well right now with kGTD, and a new app seems un-necessary, if OOP can be expanded. You already have most of the codebase written…

Geoff

09.25.06 4:22 PM

I currently use iCal (sync'd to my cell phone) and OmniOutiner Pro. What I would love to see in a GTD app is the ability to somehow link into iCal. That could be as basic as syncing todo lists with iCal, but i think there's potential for the scheduling features of iCal to tie in as well.


- Mustafa Hirji

Mustafa Hirji

09.25.06 4:41 PM

Matthew, check out this thread: http://kinkless.com/node/1028


It includes a link to this addition to the Sync applescript: http://www.studio-blend.com/dropzone/new_sync_script.txt


This fixes the completed bug and includes a work-around for when you edit tasks. Works great, and removes the one problem I had.

Benjamin Thompson

09.25.06 4:51 PM

You guys probably have this new app work with 10.5 and later, since Apple supplies the ToDo and Calender API with that, that way we can have our tasks even pop up in our webmail, and mail.app.


I'll put focus on OmniFocus on my actions list, and mail you the outcome soon.

Jacco

09.25.06 4:55 PM

OmniFu got rejected?  You have my sincerest contrafibularities, Linda.  But hearty pericombopulations to the whole team!  </blackadder>

leeg

09.25.06 5:08 PM

I use kGTD/OO/iCal while on my Mac; GTDGmail/GMail/GoogleCalendar while I'm on any other computer (mac,win,*nix); en-route my cell and paper does the job. For me syncing is a hustle, but it works more or less, but it needs to much hacks and manual labor. I'm looking forward to see what Omnigroup will offer. Good luck

—pat

Pat

09.25.06 5:10 PM

Make it übereasy to link to reference material for a project. I always have NovaMind mindmaps, Curio books and/or folders with other background material associated to projects. It should be really easy to link these to a project (and also every task connected to that project). Like dragging and dropping the reference files on the project name in a list or similar.

Oyvind

09.25.06 5:44 PM

[...] The Omni group is planning a GTD app, which will be called OmniFocus: It has a name. It has a team of engineers working on it, a user interface guru mocking up modes and widgets for it, and a product manager whose Herculean job it is to herd this whole mess towards an elusive ship date. [...]

brilliantdays.com | The race for the best Mac GTD

09.25.06 5:57 PM

OO+kGTD+QuickSilver

Bill

09.25.06 6:26 PM

Currently use iCal, Address-book, OOP and now OmniPlan.


The ability to sync data to my phone (a Sony-Ericsson P900) via iSync is fairly crucial.


IMHO iSync is still a missed opportunity (compared to what Palm desktop could do), possibly because of the closed nature of the API (at least initially).


It is great that iSync supports some many devices and connection methods but I really need to synch larger notes (even simple docs) etc (perhaps this will be addressed in 10.5 to some extent.) and this will probably need a suitable universal client app to run at the phone/PDA end….


In the meantime this OmniFocus comments list includes a great set of resources to investigate whilst we all wait for that initial Beta.


BTW: “OmniFocus” wouldn't that be a competitor to Aperture.

Black_rod

09.25.06 7:14 PM

I'm a rabid kGTD/OOP fan. (Come to think of it – sorry guys! – but kGTD is the only thing I use OOP for really.)


To me kGTD works fantastically, although I always love to tinker and there's certainly something about version updates that makes me tickled pink. Immediately I can see how you'd make such a program – eliminate the need to Sync, create more distinct operating 'modes', and just generally increase function and stability. I'd definitely say you should be in touch with Merlin and the Kinkless, if you haven't been already.


I'm looking forward to seeing what comes of Midnight Inbox. It's a gorgeous looking app and there's some things like the automated reviews that I really love about it, but it just doesn't come across as something that's going to replace kGTD anytime soon. Perhaps *because* kGTD is so…  erm… “fragile” I guess, means that it's flexible and, thus, adaptable to my own workflow. I'm not a pure GTD-er, and I don't think most people are. kGTD is fantastic because after the initial getting-to-know-it period, I feel like it's completely mine – I own it.


Anyway, for reference: I have iCal syncing enabled, but don't find myself using it that much. I'm more the type of guy who looks at my projects list once or twice a day and picks a “direction” in which to steer – my work doesn't particularly dictate that I keep a close reign on my NAs. I also ocassionally like printing index cards out, to nestle within the pages of my Moleskine pocket planner.


So there you go!

Daniel

09.25.06 7:18 PM

Perhaps OmniFu could be mistaken for “omni, FU”, as it were.

Peter

09.25.06 7:32 PM

Features I would like to see :

- A quick way to input data from the outside of the application : Thats the key in GTD idea of “inboxing”. It coud be done with a service like Yojimbo's one (which is excellent).

- An excellent Quicksilver plug-in. kGTD and general Yojimbo users know that this feature makes the difference.

- A flexible approach : like Daniel said, I think that flexibility is a good part of the succes of a GTD app.  I mean with that, that OmniFocus shoudnt be oriented only to GTD, but it could be designed as a general bucket, to track actions and items, and to organize it threedimensionally (I mean, by three kinds of abstraction, or in GTD terms, planning/projects, reviewing/next-actions, and acting/contexts.

- Integration with iCal and gCal.

- Maybe syncing between Macs.

- And strong scriptability.


Congratulations and good work OmniGroup!

Sergio

09.25.06 7:43 PM

Definitely needs syncing between Macs. *WITHOUT* having to subscribe to .Mac. I have FTP servers, WebDAV servers I can use - don't make me fork out piles of cash per annum just to be able to sync :)

TC

09.25.06 8:26 PM

I'm using kGTD with iCal sync on. To deal with two computers, I sync iCal with MySync (works great), and the kGTD document with Unison (the file synchronizer, http://www.cis.upenn.edu/~bcpierce/unison/index.html ). I also use QuickSilver a lot for rapid input of ideas, which get sorted later.


For reference storage, I use KIT (which I find more flexible than Yojimbo) for temporary storage of things to read or to organize better, and VoodooPad for long term storage.


I also have a really quick and dirty tickler system, described here http://alan.petitepomme.net/blog/files/5e244cd20a732b57b13144d73e25ed0f-48.html . It's basically a shell script run every night that looks at some files (01.txt to 31.txt, january.txt to december.txt) and email me the contents of the file. I use the QS text append functionality to add things to them, and it just works perfectly.


What I'm missing right now is a better way to do GTD on my palm. I can review my needs to be done, but dealing with current projects (adding ideas or references) is tricky as they get discarded through kGTD sync.


Sorry for the long post ;-)

Alan Schmitt

09.25.06 8:31 PM

OmniGroup's noble spirit embiggens the smallest man.

Jason Sims

09.25.06 8:37 PM

1 - Quicksilver plugin support is a MUST. 


Maybe have a plugin that allows you to quickly browse your inbox, tasks, task by tags etc in a similar interface to the iTunes browser in Quicksilver.  The ability to quickly mark items complete, or add tasks etc from any application would be superb.


2 - Get Ethan (i think his name is) from kGTD to do the design. kGTD looks beautiful with its use of bolds,  purples and transparency.

Jamie

09.25.06 8:44 PM

“Index cards all the way BABY! There like so fats and slick, I us eth blank sides of them Lets you draw and detail ideas without the useless lines.”


Yes I also think that a graphical interface is a very good idea. The possibility to move things around and setup categories and areas of interest/action as if you where operating in your mind. Also be able to throw things around a graphical calendar.


I can always dream I suppose

Grant NEALE

09.25.06 9:11 PM

moleskin. the best GTD. Use no electricity. Flexible. personal. Add pages and customize (hacks). Cool. Cheaper.

Hard to do a back up though.

chris

09.25.06 9:25 PM

[...] Wird mal wieder Zeit für ein GTD-Post. Midnight Beep Softworks entwickelt gerade mit die erste explizite GTD-Applikation namens Midnight Inbox für den Mac, also eine Software die sich nicht nur GTD-mäßig nutzen lässt, sondern explizit auf das Selbstorganisationssystem ausgerichtet ist. Bisher sind zwei Betas erschienen, die schon sehr vielversprechend sind. Lustigerweise hilft die Applikation auch ganz gut dabei zu verstehen, wie GTD eigentlich funktioniert. Beta meint hier übrigens tatsächlich Beta, so dass die Applikation derzeit noch nicht wirklich im Alltag verwendbar ist. Aber ich bin gespannt, ob sie es im ersten offiziellen Release schafft, mein Kinklesssystem abzulösen. Aber vielleicht macht auch am Ende Omnigroup das Rennen, die gerade ebenfalls eine explizite GTD-Applikation angekündigt haben. [...]

Midnight Inbox – GTD-App für den Mac -

09.25.06 9:39 PM

I use a combination of Omni Outliner Pro + KGTD, but rely heavily on index cards for daily and weekly tasks.  Personally, I try to keep KGTD as simple as possible, otherwise I find myself either not constantly updating my system or spending too much time organizing instead of getting things done.  I hope that their is a way for people to get out as much as they put in so to speak.

Sasha

09.25.06 11:58 PM

Omni- Foucs is a great name. I would like to see i have some cool representation of what you hav accomplished with a moving bar, or circle, or some other clever means, Nothing I have to do manualy, check out the Process App at

http://www.jumsoft.com/process/

coal

09.25.06 11:58 PM

I'm using iCal for dates and tasks; and I track projects in OO, but without Pro and hence without kGTD. Focus would do well to allow for viewing by project, or by tasks by context (ie, all @computer tasks, sort of a “hoist by context) irrespective of project. I think Palm sync is somewhat important, but if you could manage to sync it with iCal and let Missing Sync or iSync and iCal handle that heavy lifting, you could stay away from the complications that come with syncing and focus on a good standalone app. Also, a way to “glue” support materials by project would be important (Entourage does this pretty well), similar to the way that OO supports file linking. Another idea would be a kind of custom viewing system, whereby users could sort and view tasks by information or keyword, such as due date, person(s) or teams involved, agendas by person, etc.

Alex

09.26.06 12:26 AM

I work in a Windows world, and relax at home with my Mac. I would love some sort of way to be able to at minimum, view my projects/actions from my PC, or at best, be able to manage my details from a PC.


I know, I know, you're a Mac shop. But spare a moment for us forced to use a PC. Until I can find a good, cross-platform solution, I'm forced to use two entirely different GTD solutions!

Nick

09.26.06 12:50 AM

Tracks server side - for projects

http://www.rousette.org.uk/projects/


An excel file that looks like Joes Goals - for habits

http://www.joesgoals.com


A text file with weekly, monthly, and years - for goals


And… a text file (to-day list) where I type out what I want to do today after looking at all of my other tools/lists/stuff - for daily agenda

ewonk

09.26.06 12:55 AM

Sync with multiple Macs.

Jay

09.26.06 12:57 AM

1.sync with ical

2.quicksilver support of course

3. export to ftp version (like exporting dynamic html with OO but with upload)

ezi

09.26.06 1:25 AM

not having to press sync to see updated actions like in kinkless is a MUST

ezi

09.26.06 1:26 AM

how about integration with OmniPalm?  ;)

TL

09.26.06 2:06 AM

I second (third? fourth?) integration with a PDA…either through iCal or through a tailor-made solution. But the PDA route is ever-so-important.

talazem

09.26.06 2:25 AM

I've been using Omni Outliner for quite a while. I've had a hot-and-cold relationship with kGTD, so I've recently shifted to using OOP for planning and Journler for the rest of GTD functionality. See these links for details:


http://journler.phildow.net/


http://scarfone.blogspot.com/2006/07/journler-perfect-program-for-gtd-on.html


Looking forward to seeing OF.


Tim

Tim Elliott

09.26.06 2:31 AM

I am currently using my hipster PDA (a stack of high-tech index cards).


I can't wait =D .

Benry

09.26.06 2:40 AM

Maybe some sort of collaboration with a few web-based/PDA-based GTD app developers on some sort of GTD sync?


Failing that, a way to export a few days of tasks, so someone can write a J2ME app that can at least read the export file.


I am still trying to decide whether to go for kGTD (and suffer less than perfect iCal->iSync->Nokia E61 translation) or whether to just use Tracks - http://www.rousette.org.uk/projects/  - and fiddle with the views so as to make a QVGA-scale interface.

Michael Houghton

09.26.06 2:54 AM

Sounds great!

1. Sync with iCal.

2. Sync with Palm.


I'm using DateBk6. Solid program.

David Bourbon

09.26.06 3:12 AM

I'm using Kinkless with OO Pro. I really like the simplicity and low overhead nature of this combination, so I'm hoping OmniFocus will follow the same principle.

matt

09.26.06 3:59 AM

Using Kinkless & OOP. 

You probably thought of this, but it'll be nice if this thing interfaces to both OOP & OmniPlan

Matthew Barker

09.26.06 4:29 AM

Currently not using anything as I haven't found a solution I like.  I have great hope for OmniFocus and I'm confident you will release a great product.  One of the most important features for me is being able to Sync with a Treo as I need access while on the road.  Ideally, I would like to sync directly to the Treo without having to run it through iCal as I'm not a big fan of iCal.

Steve

09.26.06 5:32 AM

Until now I use a homegrown solution based on filemaker8. Kinkless has to many bugs and man/timetraps.Please keep your application as simple as possible. iCal, Mail integration and sync with external devices are important for me.

While Quicksiler plugins, a hurd of scripts and scriptability are NOT my first priorities.

Paul

09.26.06 5:49 AM

1.  FTP sync

2.  No dependency on .Mac

Paul

09.26.06 6:43 AM

Since you asked so nicely… :)


I'm a “pure” GTD-er, in that I run my entire life in one trusted system. Until very recently, that system was a set of index cards, as documented on Flickr. This turns out not to be very portable (although I tried), but does serve as an excellent tool for teaching you how to think in terms of GTD as a system. It also has some advantages that are barely covered by Kinkless GTD:


1.  Ubiquitous Modeless Capture - you can grab a thought anywhere (provided you're carrying note cards) and it's in the right format to drop directly into the right “place” in your system.


2.  Sketches and notes together - you don't need to change modes to jot a quick image of what you're trying to accomplish, if that's the simplest way to describe the project you're doing.


3.  Spread and shuffle - you can pick up a stack of cards and quickly shuffle through them to review your lists. There's something quite tactile and important about that interaction.


4.  Data Integrity - it's hard to corrupt an index card.


I still use the cards as a sketchbook and notebook, and I plan things out with them before inputting into Kinkless. It's still how I recommend newbies to GTD “sort out their head.” Your card-pile lists are easily copied into any more sophisticated tool later, if you so choose.


Most importantly, I print my action list and project summary onto cards. iCal and Palm sync are a horrible hack, and in my view there is no good way to fix it. I know I'm not alone in this: “sync to index cards” is a hugely useful way to take your GTD system with you.


After all, the index card is the sacred totem of the GTD geek. (Moleskines are another sacred object, but I've yet to fit one into my inkjet printer. :))


Anyway, that's my two cents.


Cheers, 

JoshD

Josh DiMauro

09.26.06 6:59 AM

I use three systems, mainly.


For the “Big Picture” of what I have to do, the one-time projects, the oddball repeating events, one-time Internet shopping lists, etc. I use Kinkless, with numerous attachments to other outlines, text and Nisus Writer Express files.


In my front pants pocket* I keep my Palm. It is used mostly as a calendar and alarm system (DateBook 5), grocery list manager (HandyShopper), and home cleaning outline (ShadowPlan, though I'd love an OmniPDA). I occasionally jot down items for my KGTD file, but not often.


Third, newest, and also in my pocket is a stack of binder-clipped index cards. I've used DIY Planner to print some reference cards and forms, but most cards are blank for hand-outs, quick notes, etc.


What I want in OmniFu ...

  - Palm synching

  - ability to print to my index cards

  - good integration with other Mac apps: Mail, address, iCal, Quicksilver

  - the ability to attach files to action items


—Liz

Housewife Extraordinaire

Liz

09.26.06 7:01 AM

* Oh, the footnote from my last post ... LLBean is the only manufacturer I know who makes woman's pants with truly useful front pockets. I can keep my Palm, Hipster PDA, Swiss Army knife, and a mini-pen in my right pocket.

Try that in your low-rise skin tight jeans, fashionistas!

Liz

09.26.06 7:04 AM

I vote for OmniFu too.


I use Kinkless+OOP+ a A4 Notebook for the notes. I am a project manager and have, accoriding to David Allens Def. at last count 87 active projects that I am working on during the week.


I also work on my PhD thesis and a number of private projects.


My big wish for OmniFu would be: Having a way to easily switch between “modes”, i.e.: I want to go from “work” straight to “private work” or “thesis” without having to put in 5 more contexts or create another private file, or, worst: having to look at all the stuff i am waiting for to arrive in my inbox at work while working on my thesis at university.


Hope its clear what I am talking about.


Thanks, pat

pat

09.26.06 7:27 AM

I use what works best, which always seem to change.  The one standby for me is a hipster - it's just a question of how the hell to process the data.  I'd love to see a kinkless-like thing with the ability to capture extra information ala Yojimbo or Devon.  That way I can keep all my notes, data, ideas, lists and GTD stuff in one handy place.


Of throw in the kitchen sync, and do it .macless. Scripting and services make me happy.


And I like OmniFu - just saying it makes me feel embiggened.


Brad

Brad

09.26.06 8:03 AM

I´d really love to see you guys consider Ethan Schoonover´s thoughts in your application! With KGTD he diverted OmniOutliner from its intended use in such a brilliant way, although it´s quite bulky.


For me GTD is about and accessing and storing tasks and ideas as soon as they come up.


Personally I would appreciate a GTD application most which go´s out of my way while I´m working but is accessible from everywhere within the system at the same time. At the same time I would love an easy way to output (publish and print) and input data (like syncing with other devices and apps).


Example: for storing useful Information in DevonThink I use that simple Bookmarklet in my Browser which fits perfect for me since this is the place where my “info gathering” actually happens most likely. Another really useful thing is 37signal´s Backpack, where I can add tasks via SMS directly to a list.


Anyway… I´m quite optimistic that you guys will amaze me with an excellent application like you always do :)

Stefan Rudersdorf

09.26.06 8:27 AM

i'm using kinkless, but would gladly pay for a dedicated program that had omni's great looks and ease of use. would prefer to have all of the GTD principles built right in, and then users through preferences can pick and choose which GTD aspects to use or not use. would love .Mac, mail, ical and address book communication and interaction, and ability to access the program through the web. check out “Inbox” from Midnight Beep, they're doing a similar GTD-like program, probably your main competitor…

Aaron Butler

09.26.06 8:37 AM

I'm currently using Kinkless as my workhorse for action lists, and I really like the way it does things. I do wish, however, that I could easily print up a set of index cards (or a four-up index card layout that I could cut out of 8x11) that already had my action lists sorted by context on them. For a while, I was printing up DIY hipster templates and writing my tasks by hand for mobile referencing. I've since started using my Palm again now that a workaround exists for the iCal syncing bugs in Kinkless, but I still think the idea of easily printing index cards has legs.


It would be super if the same system could import iCal data for printing as well.


Maybe simpler than any of that (and trying to please every user with the perfect printing format) is just to have some kind of template-based printing system. Let users contribute XML or Webkit documents that describe popular templates, then you wouldn't have to bear the entire burden of designing how things should print.


I guess, just make printing flexible enough that I can conceivably do whatever I need to with it.

MEP

09.26.06 8:46 AM

kGTD + QuickSilver +.Mac sync ...


... then we're cooking on gas with all the ssential functionality.  OmnniFocus is a bit crap as a name.  Why not just go for the simple “OmniGTD” ... says it all without sounding like a bad corporate away trip.

Alex

09.26.06 10:14 AM

Pretty much jumped up & down when I saw an GTD Omni app was on it's way! I use Omni Outliner Pro for most projects, love the ability to attach files so I always have in one place whatever I need for any specific project (very web, file & image driven). Started using Kinkless, missing an easy way to see what needs to be done next independently from the context. Also missing ability to sort by whatever extra column I add (I use an A1-C3 column for labelling importance of projects, but doesn't help if I can't sort). Killer feature will be ability to use on multiple macs & sync w/ Treo (or w/ Apple PDA:-) OmniFocus: Great name by the way!

Naomi

09.26.06 10:15 AM

I used Kinkless with OOP, but am a bit unsatisfied with the “sync” procedure.  Obviously if you designed an app ground-up you could avoid the AppleScript mess (though it is quite clever).


FOR OMNIFOCUS:

iCal integration would be KEY,

and I'd also like to have some integration with Mail.app and Address Book (an “Email John with detals of meeting” task would be much more elegent this way, for example).


Also, a Palm conduit would be nice, but I'm sure you've got other things to worry about.

Henry

09.26.06 2:44 PM

I'm using OmniOutliner, Mori, Tinderbox, and Inspiration.


For me, Spotlight integration is a MUST. I'd also like to be able to create projects (like Curio), so that I can see at a glance what I've accomplished in a paricular project.


Also an archiver, so I can remove Done work easily.


Many thanks! Sounds great, can't wait to see what you produce.


Cheers


Angela

angela

09.26.06 4:53 PM

blackberry syncing. due dates automatically sorted, show up on that day in iCal.

Skylar

09.26.06 6:02 PM

Well I use kGTD with OmniOutliner Pro and sync to iCal. Most important, however, is that I use Growal and the SendtoKGTD Advanced script to send my tasks kGTD. Also important for me is the integration with Mail. There I use MailActOn and SenttogGTD scripts again. Having a single Inbox is crucial to me, but is not yet quiet achieved with the combination of all these apps and scripts, but it gets close.


Well, for a personal organiser I use Dossier and VoodooPad Pro to capture my notes off meetings and notes that shall go to a sort of permanent knowledge base. Unfortunately those are not linked to neither iCal nor kGTD today, nor are they linked to mails that come in and shall be stored. I tried to improve this process by useing MailTags. That is though only partially successful. The main reason is that the notes put into MailTags are not properly synced with kGTD. Otherwise that would be of great help. So I use some home made scripts to extract email attachements and store them in central places that related to projects. I then grab them once a week during the weekly review to relate them back to kGTD.


So enough for the moment


Cheers


Mario

Mario Batz

09.26.06 7:19 PM

It would be really great if support for entourage syncing could be added. That would seal the deal for me.


Thanks

Sukaina

sukaina

09.26.06 7:27 PM

Using kGTD + OO.  Use excellent scripts from Niks Crappy Software website as well.  In particular, I use Send to kGTD Advanced, kGTD2Go, OmniOutliner List Manager, and I'm trying to implement Mail to kGTD.  I recommend you consult with Nik.  The man has ideas!


Desires:

1)  Be able to export to notes in iPod, as in kGTD2Go

2) GTD is about lists and actions to get things out of one's head.  I would like to be able to keep multiple pages of lists in a single GTD document of which the front page is the kGTD like taskmaster.  Ideally, there would be tabs at the bottom of the page like in Excel for viewing other pages of lists - career goals, shopping lists, etc.

3)  I would like small links to relavant documents or e-mail messages.  An extreme example will illustrate this.


I've been getting large numbers of e-mail messages advertising opportunities for our undergaduates.  Goal - Make a webpage describing these for student access.  Action #1 might be create a single list in a LaTex or other text document.  Action # 2 might be organize these by types -  scholarships, talks, international travel, etc.  Ideally, under the first action I have a string of couple dozen small yellow circles (buttons links), each linking to an e-mail message that opens when the button is pressed.  An option might allow assigning titles to each circle (link.)  When I take action, I begin by opening all these links.  After creating the file with this list, I create a small yellow button link below the second action to this list.  The point is, simple and small links to e-mail messages, documents and iCal items.

3)  Although you likely wish the product to be widely useable, not just a GTD app, it would be nice if the GTD options are the default settings.

4)  Speaking of list pages, and particularly of shopping lists, how about a way to create a master list of groceries available with check boxes, from which checks are made before a sync gives an actions list with the only the checked groceries listed in categories of like items for easier shopping (produce, canned vegetables, meat, cereal, etc.)  Then I can export to iPod notes!

5)  Option to limit import to iCal to “next tasks.”

Kent

09.26.06 11:05 PM

Yet another user of the Kinkless GTD > OmniOutliner stack, syncing to iCal and Palm Tungsten T3.

Simon Pride

09.26.06 11:43 PM

Reading some of the comments reminded me that it should support Quicksilver (I assume that's what Mario Batz means by “Growal and the SendtoKGTD Advanced script”) at least as well as kGTD does, and preferably better. It'd be nice to direct a task to a specific category and/or project if you know it at capture time. I know this violates pure kGTD by mixing the collection and processing phases, but if you already have the context in mind, why postpone the processing?


S

Simon Pride

09.26.06 11:48 PM

I am currently pulling my hair out with Entourage.


I WANT - task templates!  I have a workflow, that I repeat to make a money.  I need a master template that I can customize the name of, and dates to.  But in setting up this template I need to be able to set a master date, to which the pre-timed tasks and the post event timed tasks will fall in relation to the event.  This would give me reminders to do such things as 'check to see if customer x has paid their account in full'.  Whereas now, I would have to spend 3 months entering task, reminder and event information into my calendar and such.


Of course I need the whole shebang to be sync'd to my palm and laptop at any point….

Neil

09.27.06 12:07 AM

Please please please, include .Mac synchronization. I want to be able to sync between work and home.


As to what I'm using at the moment: VoodooPad Pro. Something more customized would be preferable though…

Steve

09.27.06 12:32 AM

I was using two text files and copy pasting between them and more recently between two omnioutliner files. However, this becomes very quickly too combersome when the number of tasks and size of projects increases.


So such an app would be a goood idea as no planning application I have come uppon really answers my need. KGTD was missing one major feature for me; to be able to answer quickly the question “When can you do this for me?”. I tried to add myself the feature to KGTD but I was bogged down by Applescript.

it would be great if such an application would allow automatic display of an alternate view displaying the tasks in a calendar form to allow to see if one is overbooking his days (always been my problem). This view would also allow to change the start date of a task just by dragging a task under another day. For example, based on start date, due date and time estimate; the tasks could be showed in this form(could also include the context):


Monday

pr 1 task 1     3h

pr 2 task 2     15 mins.

pr 1 task 3     4 h

pr 2 task 3     3h

      total       10h15  

Henryk

09.27.06 1:12 AM

I started out using kGTD, but now use Tracks.  I really wanted to be able to access my GTD list from anywhere and the development trunk version even has the beginnings of a mobile version accessible using a Palm or cell phone.

Chris

09.27.06 1:12 AM

[...] I don’t have much to add to Ethan’s (typically entertaining and gracious) post about OmniFocus — an under-development OmniGroup app that will bring Kinkless‘ functionality to a stable and powerful Cocoa application. But, first off: Yay! The Kinkless is dead! Long live the Kinkless! [...]

Ethan on Kinkless and OmniFocus | 43 Folders

09.27.06 2:03 AM

I use KGTD+OOP+iCal.  I'd like better iCal and Mail.app integration, and support for sync'ing URLs between my GTD app and iCal.  I spend a lot of time offfline and record URLs for later checking, and right now OOP puts URLs into a format that does not sync with iCal.  As for better iCal integration, the sync'ing between KGTD and iCal is not reliable for me - I've had To Do's disappear and checked items off that never get checked off in the sync.  And I'd like built-in integration with Mail.app, instead of 3rd-party scripts.

Jonathan

09.27.06 2:42 AM

Despite my deep down best of intentions, and many minor life-hack rubber band solution implementations, I still haven't been able to settle on athe right GTD system for me.

I was kind of hoping “Inbox.app” might be my dream solution.

Don't know if my user-class is a target of yours, but I'd love to give it a whirl.

Barry

09.27.06 2:46 AM

Another OO/Kinkless/iCal sync user.  If it could sync to an online calendar as well, such as Google Calendar, I would truly be in GTD nirvana.

Scott McReynolds

09.27.06 2:55 AM

Can't wait either. Been using kinkless GTD for a few months now and it's great but have been getting a few script errors. As an integrated app, I'm sure they can give it a lot of stability and lots of features.


A few wishes would be to have it integrated with the upcoming Leopard Mail ToDo feature.


And a companion app on the Palm so you see your GTD list in the same way as on your desktop (instead of it being synched with Palm's “Tasks” app)


Go Omni!

haj

09.27.06 3:04 AM

I am currently using Life Balance on my Mac and Palm TX, along with a separate OmniOutliner Pro file that just keeps track of projects.


What I like about Life Balance:

-top-level entries allow me to keep broad categories straight (e.g., research, teaching, leisure, home maintenance, “small tasks”)

-syncs with the Palm

-great support for contexts (places)

-support for one-time tasks, dated tasks, scheduled tasks (i.e. repeating on a fixed schedule) and routine tasks (i.e. “every 5 days” but not on a fixed schedule)

-tasks for a project can be set so they appear in sequence (step 2 doesn't appear until step 1 is checked off) or all at once


What I don't like about Life Balance:

-impossible to edit multiple entries at once

-user interface on the Mac still has too much Palm legacy, e.g., separate tabs for setting context, time, and notes

-calendar integration on the Palm side but not the Mac side


Llamagraphics is preparing a major upgrade that might address some of these issues, but I'd certainly give OmniFocus a try, especially if it offered a Palm version.

Brian Ogilvie

09.27.06 3:17 AM

I use Journler for my next actions, references, and journaling.


I use OOP for project planning and vertical planning, because of the handy sections as well as folded editing.


I would love for an app to have a mix of the two.

Anneliese

09.27.06 3:21 AM

I'm stuck with Entourage b/c of Exchange support.  Sync to that and I'll buy it!  Oh, and Quicksilver support.

steve

09.27.06 3:25 AM

I'm using kGTD like a madman.  I can no longer live without it.  I will definitely be shelling out cold hard cash for OmniFocus (or whatever it's called eventually)!  Woo!

Chad

09.27.06 3:32 AM

Using OOPro & Kinkless right now, but am very excited and ready to shell out cash for OmniFocusFu. 


What do I want to see?  Simple way to filter and review projects and desired outcomes based on realm (50,000 foot>Runway to use GTD terminology).


That being said, don't even waste time considering my suggestion right now—show me the beta!

b.j. abernethy

09.27.06 3:39 AM

llamagraphics' lifebalance, which is ok, but certainly lacking in the visual design and UI touches that I know you guys will do well with. (I agree with Brian Ogilvie above.)


Requirements:


FLEXIBILITY

- don't force me to fill in every little piece of data for the system to work

- let me implement customize how I use the GTD principals


SYNCHRONIZATION

- def with iCal, both ways. From there I can get most places I'd want to.

- careful about using the Location field in iCal, though—it doesn't sync to iPods. (Dumb Apple!)


REPORTING/CALENDAR VIEWS of Done an unDone tasks.


Multi-user/ability to assign tasks to a team would be great, too.

sprug

09.27.06 4:01 AM

This is the best news ever! Can't wait to get my hands on the beta. Is it possible to give us a rough idea of when to expect the first beta?

Chris

09.27.06 4:21 AM

Unfortunately those are not linked to neither iCal nor kGTD today, nor are they linked to mails that come in and shall be stored. I tried to improve this process by useing MailTags. That is though only partially successful. The main reason is that the notes put into MailTags are not properly synced with kGTD.


This should change soon as I am adding Applescripting to MailTags.  So hopefully some applescript processes (such as kGTD) will start working with metadata such as project, keywords and due dates.

 

Smorr

09.27.06 4:30 AM

I've just switched from OOP/kGTD to using FreeMind to give me a sexy little mindmap of all my tasks, cos kGTD has been playing funny recently, and I missed a meeting because of it.  I would go back to it if I could trust it again, but I have just started really, REALLY liking using mindmaps, so how about some sort of integrated mindmapper?(and not that Omnigraffle semi-effort either)


God, I do love Omni products though, although I still say that charities should get a discount, cos we need it more than students ever will…

Keith Bolshaw

09.27.06 4:35 AM

Some method of displaying your current action list (or just a specific context) really quickly on the desktop, similar to using remind in combination with Geektool. This way I can get a quick glimpse of my tasks anytime from anywhere. Maybe a dashboard widget would work too.

MEP

09.27.06 4:43 AM

Hi there! I'm using a similar system as has been suggested - onminioutliner Pro / Kinkless , syncing to ical then onto missing sync so my tasks sync with entourage at work and my PocketPC (roll on the iphone). Task management & implementing GTD and prioritising my messy life! Good luck sounds exciting!

John Paul Fitzpatrick

09.27.06 4:49 AM

A few thoughts on the omni-app in production…


I suspect a number of users here will agree with the concept of being an app that does its main purpose very well, with the ability to link to other apps with flexibility.  So, a specific calendar inside this app may not be something that's worth doing.  iCal does many things quite well, and is widely used with kGTD.  Extending Syncing ability to iCal is a useful thing- especially when coupled to online iCal webdav support (like gCalendar).


I think the ability to link to reference materials inside the app, or even the ability to use the same file add-in system that OOp uses (control-adds or adds into the files) may be quite useful for reference materials being on-hand quickly for tasks.


As well, I think there's an easy-breakdown when it comes to actual “next actions” and parent/sibling actions.  It would be wonderful if the option to list only the actions currently doable in the context lists were available.  This is the key to paring down long lists.  These long lists often have actions which are inter-related and need to be completed in a specific order.  No need to clutter next-action lists with actions that can't currently be done because its parent/sibling is not complete.  This is the one current failing in the latest version of kGTD that hurts my ability to complete my work efficiently.  [Ethan is awesome, however! please forgive the sacriledge!]


Also- btw, a linkup with Addressbook may also solve collaboration issues- should be easily done, use what apple has done to save you time- don't recode everything.  No matter what you do, there'll be people who don't like it… but if you stick with Apple-isms, you're less likely to have as many issues, I think.


BTW, I think there's some sort of synergy possible here between OminPlan and OmniFocus… many tasks are actually linked as in Gantt projects, but we rarely see these links in task-lists/to-do lists.  The option to go back and forth between project and focus may be quite an interesting aspect… just a thought…


I'm excited about OmniGroup's work here!  If this is done right, I'm sure it will garner a huge following.


My best!!

a11en

09.27.06 5:05 AM

Mail integration is what's missing from kGTD.  My inbox is where a majority of tasks start and many task end.  I use Mail Tags but there is a huge cravas between the two systems.  I need a fluid way to make the round trip between the inbox to actions / iCal and back again.


Apple should really pull ya'll in to get kGTD fully intagrated to the OS ( Mail iCal Finder iSync iPhone). 


Keep the code flowing.

Nomad

09.27.06 5:20 AM

Whew! Finally I see some other people using LifeBalance. Me too, although it's near-unscriptability is what drives me the most crazy. I know you guys generally do a good job with that, but let me specificallly encourage hook a la AddressBook. Let me add a scripted handler when a new task/item is added, when an alarm goes off, when something's completed, when something's deleted, and so forth. I don't mind flaws (which are sometimes merely design decisions I don't agree with, after all) or missing features if you give me a way to add them. And a rich selection of hooks means more users creating more 3rd party doodads and generally improving your app w/o you having to pay for the work. Heh heh.


What's really hard to add-on after the fact is synching. I've written sync systems for Entourage (with itself, laptop to desktop), and, well, don't make me have to do that again. I also don't use .Mac, but have my own WebDAV-capable server.


I actually had completed designing the logic core of my own task management system before finding LifeBalance. I really *don't* want to have to write my own.


Also, how about an item-entry system as frictionless as possible? With scripting, I can compile my own, but I thought I'd mention it anyway. :) Not only do I want to be able to hot-key open a “new task” window, but it should have as many task parameters as possible all right in front of me, with fast keyboard shortcuts for access (even if it's just tabbing over), cleverized defaults, and hopefully some kind of intelligence for figuring out where I might want to file it. Y'know, as in, if I type “Call Brenda about picnic” it guesses that this is a “contact person”-type event, maybe linking to an AddressBook entry, and/or checking for a picnic-related project under which to file this.


As long as I'm wishing, maybe user-definable datafields? Or some way, even if only through scripting, to add customized key/value data to an item other than by having to embed weird stuff in the “comments” field.


Finally, if anybody at Omni reading this was with the company back in 1993: I never got a chance to thank you guys for the NeXT Pizzabox with the SLIP connection you'd set up at WotC. It totally rocked.

Dave Howell

09.27.06 5:23 AM

I would really like the ability to easily pivot tasks between projects, urgency, and contexts. 


Tasks need to be super-easy to get in and process.


Also, I would love to be able to print to-do lists or maybe individual tasks to index cards.


Currently, I use OOP for parts of my GTD system that don't change as often (like project lists) and loose leaf or index cards for the rest.

Tim

09.27.06 7:23 AM

I am using MyLifeOrganized because of its simplicity as an outliner and its power of presenting the intersection of a next action, the project it belongs to and the context it can be done in, all in a single line item on a list.


For example, if I am looking at my @office context, I'd see a line like


Do this { Project Name }


Deceptively simple and ridiculously powerful for how I think.


The most glaring flaw in every single system I have looked at is the unwillingness or inability to implement this cross-correlation.


Please do not make the mistake of NOT including this in the first version.


It would be great if this were a Mac-and-Windows app so I could use it at home and work. I know I am dreaming on that one though.

Terrence

09.27.06 7:46 AM

I completely agree with the concept of hooks etc., here.  If you build it, the scripters will use it.  It would be wonderful if hooks could handle both *input* and *output*... then things like outputting files to text and use with geektool cli commands etc., become a possibility.  The more tools everyone has to work with, the more they'll be able to expand upon your work… just like Ethan's excellent work on kGTD with OOp.


Excited about this project guys!  :)

a11en

09.27.06 7:49 AM

I think you have to take some cues from Tracks.  Some people like the firm structure Kinkless gives, but you should definitely look at planner.el for Emacs and a long look at Tracks.  Key things from Tracks that are probably important are the ability to get data in and out of things easily, the key thing from Planner is the tie to all areas of Emacs (gnus, bbdb, etc) as well as planner-multi, which gives you flexible tags which collate multiple contexts.

TImothy

09.27.06 8:21 AM

I use a vanilla, by-the-book GTD implementation using kGTD and printed notecards for lists. I only print new cards when I do a weekly review (unless they get too marked up) and instead make the changes on paper. Because, even if the system is cool, it is about getting the stuff done, not about the system. Right?


The problem with virtually every GTD app I've ever seen is that they're much, much, much too complex. The beauty of a good GTD implementation is that the lists take care of themselves naturally with daily inbox cleaning, and the weekly review provides the automation and maintenance to keep things clean. If OmniFocus isn't measurably simpler to use than kGTD, I don't think I'll upgrade. Bells and whistles or no bells and whistles, what I need is a tool, not a geegaw.

terceiro

09.27.06 8:27 AM

A Circa notebook from Levenger and Notebook http://www.circusponies.com/


Was using kGTD and OOP, but I like the feel of paper and having more flexibility in setting up things closer to my way of thinking.


Looking forward to your application, sounds like you have all of the key players on board.


I have to say I am about sick of searching for the perfect GTD application (PGTDA).  It is like the Holy Grail!  If I had just taken the time I used searching for the PGTDA to actually get things done I'd be way ahead by now!  Is there a 43Folders Anonymous yet?

Owen

09.27.06 8:37 AM

Using Action Tracker. It is a FileMaker DB that I reconfigured to work on my Palm using FMMobile. Syncs relatively easy. Also use Fuhgeddaboutit for adding to dos from Mail.

Damon

09.27.06 8:43 AM

Currently use:

—-

+ OOP+kGTD

+ VoodooPad for notes

+ Quicksilver

+ Palm OS built-in calendar for scheduling time-sensitive events for myself

+ MeetingMaker for group events scheduled by my employer

+ iCal for work project time tracking down to the 1/4 hour

+ Google Calendar for work project planning in the “big picture” view


Yes, I use 4 separate calendar apps!


Considering: Yojimbo, Life Balance


Desired Features:

—-

+ sync with palm and network based store that doesn't require .mac (sftp, webdav, etc)

+ decouple from ical (gets too easily bogged down with significant quantity of calendars)

+ integration with web-based calendar like Google Calendar would be nice

+ linking to external resources (text files, VoodooPads, URLs, etc) maybe similar to Yojimbo

+ easy/clever ways to input data: service menu, keystroke, Quicksilver, SMS, etc

Lindsay

09.27.06 8:49 AM

please consider lifebalance-style contexts that allow time-based context blocking and overlapping.

Señor Pantalones

09.27.06 9:03 AM

I use kGTD+OmniOutliner+iCal w/ HighPriority (http://www.kudurshian.net/highpriority/)


I have two separate GTD documents, one for school and one for other projects. I usually have them both open at the same time, but I never need both at the same time. For me it would be useful to have a tabbed interface, so both documents could be open without hogging as much screen real estate.

Andrew Conti

09.27.06 9:28 AM

I use Tracks, via Zenlist (http://www.zenlist.com/), with calendering in iCal, synced to the mobile and the Palm. And Tiddlywiki for note-taking.


OmniFocus sounds good but make the data exportable in XML or RDF.

AndrewJ

09.27.06 10:10 AM

Wow - I can't believe there are so many posts over 2 days. Me? I use OO + Kinkless and print the whole list onto A4 whenever I do a review (+/- weekly). Good sync to a palm would be a welcome addition to this, though I know that Omni have been reluctant in the past. Failing that some way to access and update via a Windows-at-Work scenario would be a great bonus - even if web-based. I end up doing all reviews and GTD updates at home, which I can resent as I spend enough time at work…

B.J Abernathy's comment re 'Simple way to filter and review projects and desired outcomes based on realm (50,000 foot>Runway to use GTD terminology).' is attractive as well as ability to link to project files etc.


If it looks and feels right, then I'd buy.

David Gilding

09.27.06 10:13 AM

I have recently started using a Mac.  I like it.  But I also have to live in the other world - Windows.  I like others have posted would like to have something that could work between both worlds.  I use an application on Windows called Bonsai that syncs the outline directly with my desktop ... somthing like that with the ability to sync with a Palm would be excellent.  Or something that I could use via an internet application would be nifty too.

Dean Fuhrman

09.27.06 11:18 AM

I'm glad to hear that you folks at OmniGroup are working on this. I can't wait to see how OmniFocus shapes up.


I'm still searching for the GTD tool that works for me, so the news of OmniFocus comes at a good time.


I've tried kGTD, and I found it too convoluted for my taste.


I've checked out Midnight Inbox (http://www.midnightbeep.com) and I find it a bit confusing.


Probably the tool that I've tried that makes the most sense to me is EasyTask Manager (http://www.orionbelt.com). It's definitely got room for improvement, but it does a very straightforward job of breaking GTD down to its bare essentials. You can view by project, by context, or by calendar. It also syncs with iCal, although the synching seems to be too one-way for me.


I'd like to see OmniFocus incorporate the features that make kGTD so powerful, but with the straightforwardness that OmniGroup does so well. Something like EasyTask Manager, but executed by OmniGroup, would be great.

John Cradock

09.27.06 11:31 AM

I am voting for scriptability too. If we could self-tune this puppy to be the digital organization hub, that would be nirvana!! (Does that sentence really mean anything? Don't think so, but I am hoping you sense my drift.)

Gerry Power

09.27.06 1:07 PM

Yeah, well, don't laugh, but I use a Newton. With MoreInfo, I can link Names, Dates (Tasks, Meetings, Events), and Notes. A link is two taps away, and I can edit things on the fly. I have an archive of information, spread out without the use of folders, AND I have relevant folders that I use to give a second sorting hierarchy for classes of things I do in my life. It's a fabulous mixture and nothing on the desktop has ever come close to it.


As a result, what I want from any desktop app is:


1. seamless integration with Mail (which the Newton can't do), iCal, and Address Book.


2. Easy linking between all these data sources, so that I can change data in one location and have that data be updated in all my other lists.


3. A simple user interface which works from the get-go, totally consistent with OS X.


See, I don't doubt that you can do this. You guys rock on #3, doing #2 should be doable with the appropriate database system (on a Newton, the data “soups” are open to all programs, and the interface of a program is merely calling up specific bits of information from a given soup), and #1 is bizarrely missing from the OS X world these days.


Thanks for working on this. I look forward to using it…

Michael Wittmann

09.27.06 1:29 PM

An addition to my previous post:


On the Newton, the assistant lets me say things like “Lunch Friday John” and it will automatically populate Friday, 12 to noon, with a John in my calendar (okay, so you pick the last name instead, to be unique) and put it in my date book.


I'd like to see smart linking like that. If I have a task that involves someone's name, I want to be able to find that task when I am viewing my tasks in relation to a given person. Even if it wasn't the person or the project originally associated with the task.


Hope that makes sense.

Michael Wittmann

09.27.06 1:32 PM

Since you say this is going to be a personal organizer, I want to say you need to look at going beyond tasks and GTD. There are a couple of interesting programs that try to integrate AddressBook, iCal and mail. They are CRM4Mac and OD4Contact to be called Contactizer. These are good programs, but there is room for a killer app.


An organizer should be synced with Addressbook and iCal. There needs to be a means of taking notes. With a note, you should be able to attach any type of document or web url or photo or audio, etc.


One of the key elements for me is to be able to link notes, events, and tasks to an address record. The other key element is to have a view where I can see all of these linked elements along with all of the email I have received or sent to the contact.


It is late, so I hope I am coherent. SOHO Organizer has tried to do some of these, but not very well. I am always looking for a better method. I have tried using kGTD with OOP, but not being able to view the tasks that are linked to a contact is a big problem for me.


Looking forward to your new product.  Saving my money!

Terry Hatmaker

Terry Hatmaker

09.27.06 3:02 PM

I use the Kinkless program but find it flimsy.  II's got the righ idea though.


I really need Palm integration.  Although perhaps you could use the new game interface to get it running on the iPod (can you save/sync state?) Of course either way it's a new (to you guys) cruftier (especially in the PalmOS case—ewww) environment.


Another important feature is links, which OO can't get right: I would like to stick a message into the tickler list for, say, the 30th of next week.  You can't do that in O-O.


HTH

DV Henkel-Wallace

09.27.06 4:24 PM

Was using kGTD+iCal, but currently using Entourage (blech) because of two things: 1) Palm sync 2) project sharing with hubby. 


Having blech'ed all over Entourage a lot, there are still things I like about it, especially the project center and its ability to auto-associate incoming emails with projects based on the contact in the address book.

Lenore

09.27.06 7:38 PM

Currently with OOP/Kinkless nearly meets all i want, but heres some thoughts:


+Integrate with everything, not just mac/palm

+Keep an eye out for the new stuff and integrate (Leopard's system-wide notes/todo), New Palm OS, Widows Mobile 5 and later, symbian os

+Steal best bits from everywhere and include

+Price it accordingly to provide good support, fast bugfixes and development


Do it….yesterday ! Lang may yer lum reek…or JFDI

jeyell

09.27.06 8:07 PM

I am a profoundly visually-oriented person.  I need highly customizable visual interfaces or I can't get past the interface to get my work done.  I'm also love technology, but I'm so non-linear I can barely use most programs.  OmniOutliner is a God in my inner universe.  Without GTD, there is no life; but how to implement is my holy grail.  http://www.organzingtheself.com details my travails.  OmniFocus is my last hope. 


Use/non-use:


my mind loves the idea, but can't handle the reality of:

Kinkless GTD:  too much to do to enter an item, syncing didn't seem to work

iCal:  visual interface not customizable enough, item entry not easy enough

Tungsten palm pilot:  after 10 hours, I gave up on ever syncing this

Journier, MacJournal:  GREAT options for linking to other programs, but, no OO style lists. I need collapsing, indentation, movability, etc!

Circus Ponies Notebook:  too linear, tough interface for me.  Great vibe though.

Inbox:  interface overwhelming on first look, couldn't jump right in like OO; seems too big for me

EasyTask:  simple, quick start interface, good, but too small for me

Delicious Library:  too small for cataloguing stuff

Process:  visual interface not customizable enough.  I love OO's massive visual flexibility, can't live without it.


my current system:

OOP for all tasks

Quicksilver, of course

paper wall calendar for dates at home

back page of checkbook for dates on the road

written index cards for things to buy/do on the road

unikeep binders (http://www.unikeep.com) for projects paperwork, I worship these clear plastic boxes!

DVDpedia for cataloguing movies I want to see/have seen

palm pilot with thinkoutside bluetooth keyboard for long written notes/journal entries on the road (bluetooth sync, notes only, to iMac)

I'm thinking about trying out Yojimbo, awesome intro demo movie


What I could use in OmniFocus:


I really don't give a rat's rear end about Palm syncing, I gave up on that

I have 3 computers, this system must sync!

super-easy, integrated linking to other programs (I think this is done well by Yojimbo, MacJournal, Journier)

links to address book, iPod, .mac sync, Leopard mail to do

the 'framework' of the program works like Yojimbo, MacJournal, or Journier

inside the 'framework' is a fully functional OmniOutliner document

You can take or leave GTD functions & can make this your own—I do not want to have to assign a date to everything


Omni, you rule my universe.  I have confidence in this product!  I spend hard cash on family packs o' Omni products, and I have confidence you will turn out an Omni-riffic GTD organizational delight.  It is highly likely that I will lay down $ for OmniFocus!  Hope this helped!

Melissa

09.27.06 9:45 PM

I am truly exited by this teameffort. Omni+Ethan+Merlin! There could be no better dreamteam for the task. Please bring in some of the beauty of Midnight Inbox.

ganesh

09.27.06 10:05 PM

Some pieces of software that have something excellent about them that could inspire your approach:

Thinking Rock (OS X software)

Hiveminder (web app)

Mindcad Incubator or OmniGraffle mindmapping for the graphical bit

GTDGMail (FireFox plugin)

30Boxes (web calendar; far more flexible than Google Calendar)

I've little doubt that you'll somehow manage to cook up something that blends some of these elements into something really special.

RickL

09.28.06 12:05 AM

i bought OO Pro just to use with kGTD. i bought the GTD book and started reading it, but like most things i got bored and quit reading before i figured things out. i tried multiple times to use OO/kTGD. i lasted about a week each time. i didn't like that i'd sync with iCal and then it would create 30 calendars (or thereabouts). that's just too much to follow. in the end, i've switched to TextMate for to do lists and google calendars. i use 2 computers and this is an easy way to keep them synced.


one of the things i didn't like about the full GTD process was that i end up with a lot of tasks that are pretty small, but important (i teach). with OO/kGTD, i felt like i was sometimes spending more time trying to document the things to do than i was actually doing them. perhaps if i'd read the book better, i would have a better sense of how to organize overall and the small pieces would have fallen more easily into place??? in any regard, i'd like a way to add simple to do items quickly without a lot of razzmatazz!

sean lancaster

09.28.06 12:51 AM

Here is the thing. Think through the entire process if you want folks to use it. Remember, not everyone carries around a “device” (laptop, palm, phone) so find a way to print out a page that allows one to see what's important, and add some new notes to it. That's simple enough isn't it?

Peter

09.28.06 2:45 AM

Wow - 130+ comments.  Think there's interest in this app? 


Considering that Omni met with Ethan and Merlin a few months ago, and they're tantalizing us with this post, well—that means they've got to be close to beta.  Right?  Right.

b.j. abernethy

09.28.06 3:19 AM

i use omnioutliner and kGTD.  i used to sync with ical but now i prefer keyboard navigating the todo lists from OO.


quickly printing a next actions index card summary would be great (for selected contexts).


also, i use OO on my kGTD file for keeping track of other GTD-like things.  (in particular, i keep a daily strategy which helps me focus.)  keeping that flexibility would be nice.

dave

09.28.06 4:25 AM

Looking forward to OmniFocus.  I'm currently using Mail.app + Mail Act On + iCal + Missing Sync + Palm Pilot. :)

Michael McDaniel

09.28.06 5:23 AM

[...] Gosh, I just can’t tell if there’s enough interest in OmniFocus…maybe we should scuttle it in favor of OmniCrashDoubler 1.0, the app that crashes when you try and enter descriptive text about why your original app crashed in the first place! But only after you hit the only button available, which is helpfully labeled “crash”. [...]

The Omni Mouth » Gratitude and appreciation

09.28.06 5:46 AM

• “Publish to web” functionality (.Mac or otherwise) which allows you to snag a view (and maybe enter data as well) from semi-smart phones…


• Or perhaps that feature could be simplified with “Sync with Backpack” or some other already established Web productivity suite.


• Connectivity to the other PIM apps in OS X: AddressBook, iCal, Mail, etc.

Eric Nentrup

09.28.06 6:08 AM

A 1,000th OO/kGTD user.


- MUST MUST MUST sync to iCal -> Palm (both ways)

- Must be easy to use, back itself up, and work great.

- Working with Quicksilver is also a must


OmniFocus sounds great, but please make sure it conforms to GTD and also works with the new version of Mail and Todos in OSX Leopard.


Thanks,

BZ

BZ

09.28.06 6:35 AM

[...] My biggest change has been a move back to Voodoo-Pad from OmniOutliner, because I feel like I wasn’t getting the most out of the program (I never did get how to use columns, and I always felt like the formating, an aesthetic concern I’ll grant you, would never behave,) this I think is mostly a problem with my brain and how it works in combination with the kind of tasks that I seem to be focusing on. I learned from 43Folders that there’s going to be some sort of Omni kGTD program (a productivity methodology/application) on the heels of being released. Sweet. [...]

Being a Geek at TealArt

09.28.06 7:58 AM

[...] Wer den letzten Eintrag zu Yojimbo gelesen und weiterverfolgt hat, stieß sicherlich auf den Hinweis von Merlin über kGTDOO. Der wies auf The Omni Mouth, das Weblog der Omni Group und dort auf OmniFocus. [...]

OmniFocus « Die Kritiker

09.28.06 7:59 AM

kGTD/OOP. I'm really, REALLY happy you've decided to take up the challenge. Just involve Ethan and Merlin as much as they'll tolerate. I absolutely live inside OOP.

Dan P

09.28.06 9:29 AM

Oh yeah.  Pretty please with sugar on top.  I love buying products from you guys.  Now I'll have an application that will help me keep track of buying them.  oh yeah.

slothbear

09.28.06 10:05 AM

i tried using kinkless gtd on omni outliner, but i tend to have lots of date specific tasks.  i set up tinderbox to view actions by task, project, or timeframe.  i made agents to color tasks based on whether it's overdue, due today, in the coming week, or past that.  so far it's working pretty well, but i'm interested to see what you guys come up with for omni focus.

kiyong

09.28.06 12:25 PM

1. ability to specify whether tasks should be done “in order given” or “in any order” (which kGTD sorta kinda handles if you add “*” to the project name).


2. Handy “format for index card” option when printing


3. The name makes me think of photography. The first thing that came to mind was “OmniAction”, since it's all about the Next Action.

Baron Von Snodgrass

09.28.06 1:01 PM

Omni,


I would recommend purchasing and installing the actually Outlook plugin offered by David Allen ( http://gtdsupport.netcentrics.com/home/ ).  One thing that is missing in all the various solutions:  Directly processing your email (Mail or Entourage).  This is where 80% of all my projects, actions, etc. start.


Help me proess my inbox :-).


Stuart

Stuart Watson

09.28.06 2:00 PM

[...] No sooner do I write about getting back to basics with Getting Things Done and Kinkless GTD, then the Omni Group announces that they are developing a GTD app called OmniFocus. For those not familiar with the Omni products, they are all extremely well done: high functionality, smooth and effective user interface and extraordinary though put into how it will actually work. [...]

Nontrivial Exercises » Blog Archive »

09.28.06 3:26 PM

Named views which filter records on field values - like the old Lotus Agenda

Robin Trew

09.28.06 3:40 PM

I use kGTD (bought OmniOutliner for that reason). 

Palm sync is the vital thing for me.

John McKeown

09.28.06 5:24 PM

My paper setup before having a laptop always with me used to be a table with: task - time needed to perform this task - priority. Then I'd add up the times for today's tasks, and see how I stand against time available. Then I'd schedule tasks into events (task A 9:35-10:10 and so forth). IMO, this integration between tasks and events, including needed time, is what is really missing from all apps I've seen up to now. I can't really understand why - all tasks will have to be scheduled into my calendar to be performed at some point, and they do require a certain amount of time! If you promise to do this…

Sara

09.28.06 5:51 PM

My wish list for OmniFocus:


- release early, release often

- build half a product, not a half-ass product


I hope you know what i mean… ;-)

Obyor

09.28.06 7:39 PM

“My key demand for a GTD app is 'ubiquitiousness'.”


That sums it up for me. That's my top request for any app these days. Yojimbo is my resources catch-all for that reason. I use MailTags with IMAP for that reason. Now, if I could only find a ubiquitous GTD app…


Oh, and one more thing…


The option to use it without touching the mouse and with as few keystrokes as possible and from any app at any time. As David Allen says, the only thing that works is what you're willing to use at the most stressful or busy times.

Tim

09.28.06 8:06 PM

Oh, one more thing: for actions with a time allocated - have a one-button access to a timer pre-defined with the time allocated to the task. This could be taken further with creating 'dash' actions that will translate into the relevant timer series.

Sara

09.29.06 1:56 AM

As someone else said, don't forget to make our OO files importable into OmniFocus!

Rafa

09.29.06 4:18 AM

I bought OO to use Kinkless. Crucial parts of my use are iCal and MailTags. Looking forward to see the outcome!

Carlos

09.29.06 7:24 AM

Kinkless does so much of what I like. It's close to perfect, never quite perfect since we can all improve. I think if OmniFocus can get it's feature set in as a foundation great things can emerge. I'll list the features of Kinkless which I really like.

1. Flexibility.

Kinkless allows you to follow the GTD approach yet with the ability to customise how strict (pedantic) you want to be.

2. Implements all needs of GTD

3. iCal Integration

At the begining this feature 'wowed' me. However over time I found myself using it less and less. It's probably just me that's at fault.

4. Mail Integration

No Kinkless doesn't have it now but a few tools/scripts out there fill in the gap. It would be cool if OmniFocus could integrate Mail in an intelligent and useful way. Maybe I could tag a mail message so that it was linked to an action in OmniFocus. That way the mail message would be quickly available as a reference and would lead to less time in creating descriptive notes for an action.


I'm looking forward to what you guys come up with, good times ahead!

N Shah

09.29.06 7:35 AM

I'd love to have something along the lines of omnigraffle/ novamind/ mindmanger.  meets omnioutliner with thinkingrock and Inbox type processing. Web archiving and file tagging in a devonthink type database. Currently I use universal village collaboration suite. Problem is it's ugly and Java-ity . One feature I'd really love is to be able to select a file in the finder and create a task for that file from a contextual menu.

gilbertb

09.29.06 9:20 AM

I upgraded to OO Pro to use Kinkless. What I find most helpful is its integration w/ Quicksilver so that I can quickly get ideas into my virtual inbox.

Nick Lesiecki

09.29.06 9:53 AM

Don't know if theis was already mentioned (didn't see it in the comments feed), but the ability to import/export from OmniPlan would be great as well. That way I can reduce a project plan to just my next actions or I can convert a series of related next actions into a formal project.

Chris

09.29.06 10:08 AM

Was using Kinkless + OO, but the iCal + thence Palm syncing was frustrating, so switched to a home-brew Basecamp setup (http://www.basecamphq.com) for ubiquity.


Would love a desktop/web/PDA amalgam that synced smoothly, and was flexible enough to hold stray thoughts, ideas, snippets of websites, URLs etc, as well as the more immediate project/next action stuff.

David Moore

09.29.06 11:48 AM

Two things I would really like to see:


Task dependencies—seems like many of the tools assume that your tasks can be completed in any old order, whereas I often find myself working on projects that depend on other projects (that depend on other projects, ..., but let's not go there).


Repeating tasks—some tasks occur over and over again, and it would be useful to be able to enter them once and have them reappear on schedule (for example, paying the guy that mows our lawn (monthly),  changing backup tapes (daily/weekly), etc.)


I would also recommend taking a look at Tom Limoncelli's _Time Management for System Administrators_ (or bringing Tom in the way you brought in Merlin and Ethan).  Tom's cycle-system isn't quite GTD, but is pretty close, and there may be some ideas in there that would be worth incorporating. 


I'm definitely looking forward to the beta—thus far, everything I've tried hasn't quite worked for me.

Claire

09.29.06 9:13 PM

Full .Mac Syncing across multiple machines!!

that would be AMAZING

Skylar

09.30.06 2:01 AM

Kinkless, what else !!

karthikesh

09.30.06 2:12 AM

Fairly new to GTD, and am so far sticking to paper, because I'm not happy with any of the apps I've tried—so am REALLY looking forward to OmniFocus! The most important thing to me would be ability to tweak views. I'd like to be able to view my next actions by context, OR by project, and I'd like to be able to choose how many (or few) next actions I see.


For example, most apps show you a humongous to-do list, with several next actions for each project displayed. I'd really like the ability to decide how many next actions per project I want to see—so that if I'm feeling overwhelmed, I can cut the “next actions shown per project” down to one, thus allowing me to see a list of projects and what the *single* next action/to-do is for each one. I don't always want to see twenty next actions for every project, scattered over various contexts—that makes my to-do list a million miles long, and depressing!


As I check off one to-do, I'd like the next one for that project to slide into its place. That way I'm looking at only one to-do per project at any given time. Right now I'm doing this manually, on paper. I'd love love LOVE to have it automated in an app I can trust (which is where kGTD falls short for me).


Also, to echo the comment by Terrence above, it's really important to me to be able to see context + project + next action all hooked together. Otherwise, I lose track of what action is for what project.

duodecad

09.30.06 5:25 AM

It's all been said, but I vote for in order of preference:


1) quicksilver integration

2) email integration

3) built in FTP—(I am also fed up with .mac)

4) collaboration—assign tasks to a partner, etc.

Johnny A.

09.30.06 7:10 AM

My dearest of the dear Team Omni,

Oh, what a delight, was it to see

that you're making an app based on GTD,

for mummy, daddy, and lil ol' me :)

Hurrah! Rejoice! O Let the celebrations begin!

Finally a GTD app that's work through thick & thin :)


(Ummm…KGTD is pretty cool too, Ethan buddy,

but, Man…nothing like a GTD app from dear Omni!)


Team Omni, request I have, is but one

Please please do tell you'll get it done


My asking is simple and quite straightforward, you see;

please please do somehow have OmniFocus sync with…..my Blackberry


You see, till now there ain't an app that syncs

blackberry to a mac without any kinks


Without a BB sync, I tearfully surmise

OmniFocus wud be another app not for us BB guys :(


this is a corny rhyme, I know, you don't need to mention,

but hey,  I really hope it got your attention.


ever hopeful BB-user-and-Omni-Fan,

Arif

(Bangalore, India)

 

Arif

10.01.06 3:48 PM

Omni shouldn't be expected to produce a companion Palm app, there is existing script for export to ShadowPlan, if that could be worked up into a nice conduit to ShadowPlan that would be great.

john mckeown

10.01.06 6:24 PM

I use DayLite, but could be persuaded to change.

Karen

10.02.06 4:13 AM

Before you get too far in omnifocus development, I would encourage you (and i suspect you already are) to develop the omnifocus app with one eye on OSX Leopard, especially as it pertains to iCal integration into the OSX system. Go to this link for some brief information about iCal in OSX (http://www.kinkless.com/node/981) . I believe any information organizing tool should have elegant iCal integration. As you will see from the information I'm referring you to, iCal integration probably becomes even more relevant in Leopard.


P.S. The text from the link above is also pasted below. Thanks for your work on this.


iCal in Leopard

Posted in kGTD General Discussion by Peter Herndon on Wed, 2006/08/09 - 4:06pm

There’s been some really nice announcements from Apple’s WWDC regarding iCal in Leopard, that are potentially very pertinent to kGTD users.


One important announcement was that iCal will gain an API. Another was that iCal will become the front-end to a calendaring/scheduling/to-do database, and that database will be accessible to any/all applications. Another was that to-do’s will be creatable via the Services menu — in short, a new to-do can be created with a right-click on pretty much anything.


The final pieces of goodness are that iCal is becoming a CalDAV client, a CalDAV server is planned to ship with Leopard Server, and if you don’t feel like waiting for Leopard, the server is available open source at http://trac.macosforge.org/projects/collaboration


What this means: GTD apps can work with iCal’s database via its API directly, rather than using AppleScript. Furthermore, there’s a server available, so GTD for groups (what a concept!) is possible. Also, since it’s standards-based, interoperability with Mozilla Sunbird, Chandler, and other CalDAV clients (Outlook is mentioned) becomes possible — which means one can have cross-platform GTD apps that all touch the same calendar backend.

John

10.02.06 10:06 AM

I agree with earlier comments that there should be some solid syncing with Palm (and maybe even windows) based PDAs.

John

10.02.06 10:08 AM

OmniFu!  I like this too!


I would like iPod syncing, especially if it can be done in such a way that it's autosynced when the iPod is connected, regardless of the state (launched or not) of OmniFu.

Nutrimentia

10.02.06 1:16 PM

I used to be a Palm person, but am finding that I just don't have the energy to carry yet another device given I get decent contact/schedule support on my phone.  This works ok with kGTD, but only in a read-only fashion.  What I'd really plunk down the $$ for is some sort of J2ME capture app for the smartphone which syncs to my computer-based GTD app.

Ben

10.03.06 1:25 AM

For me, it HAS to sync with Entourage AND Palm - that's worth paying money for. Otherwise, I'll stick with Shadow, or LifeBalance, or some other equally cruddy product (I've tgried most of them….)

anonymouse1

10.03.06 6:53 AM

I've just started using kGTD with OO. It would be great to sync with PDAs directly without having to go through iCal.

Azam

10.03.06 2:22 PM

oh my goodness I hate iCal !!  Please don't make iCal a requirement, have at least a minimal calendar and alarming system.


For me it is essential that reminders be sent through email.  This implies a server-side component so you guys probably won't do it.  But everything in my life touches email (eventually).  How about a plugin system for notifications?  Then people could use Growl, or email, or whatever they like for notifications.


I use Yahoo Calendar to send me email reminders and it works great.  Being able to email reminders to *other people* would also be fantastic.

peliom

10.03.06 9:45 PM

What I would like is a modern version of Lotus agenda with user-defined groupings, views, and categories.

Graham

10.04.06 4:00 AM

I'm currently using kGTD and OmniOutliner Pro.  It's doing alright, but it gets quite buggy.  Hopefully OmniFocus can pick up exactly where kGTD leaves off

Derek

10.04.06 6:50 AM

I'm forever going to think of it as OmniFu in my head, though.

Shannon

10.04.06 8:12 AM

Like a lot of people here, I use OOP and kGTD, and bought the first to use the second.

Unlike others, I also use TimeTo on my PC (which sits on my desk right next to my Mac).  Check out the app at http://www.davidberman.com/software/timeto.php)

What I like about the programme is its ability to dynamically schedule tasks, and its flexibility.  Not wild about its interface, but Mac has spoiled me :)

From what others have said here, I'm not sure that this kind of approach is where you're going with OmniFocus/OmniFu… but TimeTo has been a godsend to me.  I used to spend tons of time feeling guilty when I had to re-schedule items that I Had Not Done (interruptions, whatever); now it's pretty much done automagically.

In fact, that's the main reason I hauled my old PC back onto the desk—to use TimeTo.  Would love to stick the PC back in the closet again… :-D


Just my 2¢—your mileage may vary.

David

10.04.06 3:59 PM

[...] I decided to use Kinkless GTD because it seems to be fairly mature given what it is and Omni are working on OmniFocus. I already had a license for OmniOutliner (2 actually because one was included with my MacBook Pro) so I upgraded to Pro and got started populating my Projects and Actions from my mind sweep list. So far Kinkless seems to be working well but I can definitely see that creating the appropriate set of contexts will take some time. To that end I’m considering using Fast User Switching to simulate a work environment vs. a home environment for my computer use. If anyone has tried [...]

First Steps into GTD « Mullery

10.05.06 12:14 AM

I'm a law student who uses:


OOP for class notes/outlines

DEVONthink for research/writing

LifeBalance on Mac and Treo 700p for GTD

moleskine/sticky notes for collection

iCal (calendar only)

Mail.app

Quicksilver

Quicken 2004

Firefox


The functionality of LifeBalance is unbeatable for me at the moment but the interface is abominable. I LOOOOVE OOP interface, so have high hopes! :)

Lindsey O Worth

10.05.06 6:33 AM

HI,


it amazes me only one post mentioned d3 (dcubed a TiddlyWiki plugin/ adaptatiom)


I use it plus the Joel's Painless soft ware schedule plugin.

I also in the last year used the monkey GTD and GTD plus (all TiddlyWiki adaptations or plugins.


It rocks: it is portable (Javascript), runs on major browsers, you can put it on a USB and carry it with you 6 therefore share between home (mac and work (Win). It Prints to cards.

It doesn't run on a mobile phone (I have an SE P900) because the browsers on there do not support JavaScript. On the P900 I use an outliner called projekt, from kylom.com. Brilliant. It can sync OPML with OO.


For some work stuff ( I use Basecamp, because it is so easy to set up ilestones and associated to dos. Godd for tracking my waiting stuf and more flexible than a calendar.


My biggest wish (which I think no other GTD app or system covers) is a way to support the Natural planning process in The GTD book. I never saw any thing about identifying components, sequences & priorites in any GTD tools. I loved this section of the book because it really does seem to hold the essence of the complicated project management techniques. But also to be a useful tool for beating a load of fuzzy actions into shape.


I have found the concept of 'need clarity?' => go back to caturing ideas, what?, principles and why?,

and the complementary

'need more to happen'? => more detailed planning

very useful to keep me on track and able to get over those postponing moods.


I would like a way to assist with the STING process for fighteîng procrastination & lack of focus:

S - select one task

T - time yourself (countdown timer :-)

I - ignore everything else (hide all other content, stop email alerts etc.)

N - no breaks

G five yourself a reward. (hold a list of favourite rewards and then pop one up at random if focussed. at the end of the tmer period.)


I also am puzzeled because my reading of GTD makes me think DA is advocating - just thinking of one action when you have a project in mind. Adding it too the list, & moving on. Most of the systems I see you end up with an enormous list of stuff to do, which gets to looking more & more like the old style TO DO. It seems to me david's message is impotant here - you do not need to plan a whole project - to make progress one bit at a time


And support brain storming too, with drag/ drop to projectify or actionate items. there needs to be a way to promote / demote actions and projects.


I would like to add deBONO's six coloured hats also to the NPP as a frame work for evaluating possible actions in programs. Perhaps add a hat icon to comments/ notes on to dos. allowing grouping or sorting by it.


I have to say I am also a fan of Tinderbox, but use it less than i could because it is mac only. The same thing applies to Omni-x sadly. Although Omnigraffle is SO much better than Visio I go home and do that work there…


oops more like 3 cents :-)


daveG

DaveG

10.05.06 8:22 AM

I currently use Omnioutliner Pro, in which I have a list of todos, with columns showing start date, day of the week, time, completion date and a task completed check off box. Once completed I manually move tasks to a task completed section, that way the todolist is always unchecked tasks and select-row-sorted by start date. It would be nice if my tasks showed up in ical automatically. I'm grateful for the displayed-in-pane narrative note section, because I don't want notes mucking up the todalist. I often refer to past completed tasks for info about what went wrong, who said what, and how it all came together, etc. Without it, a task manager would be a waste of time for me. It is important to me for a todolist to take up a small space on the screen, because I almost always use it juxtapose with another application. I need information from it, or add to it, but don't want it to cover up whatever else I'm doing.

Richard Crosby

10.06.06 1:01 AM

I was rather hoping that it would make an interesting anagram.  Scum of Ion was the best that I could come up with!  Omingraffle is of course Male Griffon or Minor Fag Elf!

Andy

10.06.06 10:51 PM

Phew, that is quite some read from top to bottom.


I looked at kGTD and considered buying OOP on the strength of it, but as I already have NoteBook there seemed little point.


NoteBook has many strengths, but weaknesses too.  On my 1.33 PB with 1.25GB RAM it syncs with iCal very slowly.  I would also like it to be able to print out some of my lists to 3x5 index cards.


I never liked the look of OOP.  NoteBook looks so much better.


My system comprises of a stack of index cards and a pen.  When I am at the computer I just type everything in the Next Actions section and move it from there.  I review 10 - 20 times a day to see how things are shaping up and what I can do to get through the rest of the tasks.


OmniGraffle is the only application that I have registered, but Omnif* might make a convert out of me, but it would have to be outstanding to make me change from NoteBook

Andy

10.07.06 12:59 AM

I'm using the next to most recent version of the kGTD with Omni and its almost totally perfect for me. I'd like a better integration with iCal because right now I'm just not using it. The most recent update to kGTD killed the project view which is what I use most of the time.

But really, iCal is less important to me than a .mac sync so I can use this on my laptop and at home. Right now its a stricktly work utility. Thats all I see iCal being good for.

But I have generally 4 to 10 big projects on my desk at work for two or three different clients so I nest the projects under the client name which makes the project view easy to jump between clients or projects. And then I use the different Actions segments when I'm working.

Alan

10.07.06 2:39 AM

kGTD+OOP+Quicksilver is a nice combination.  I tried FileMaker7+FMMobile7 for Palm sync—but FMMobile cannot sort by more than one field—a dealkiller for me.  I have 3 lives, PhD work, employer work, and home that I need to keep together.  WindowsPC at work, Treo at all times and HanDBase rocks on Palm, but minimal Mac integration, Mac for the entire rest of my life.  Syncing either WebDAV or .Mac, and some way to get it to Treo would be heaven.  Icing on the cake would be tasks that change color or sort order as they age, so I could more easly see when I'd ignored something way too long.  Customisable when the aging starts without having to designate a true due date.  Output to index cards, as I carry a stack with me to capture tasks fast, and analog backup saves us when Kurt Russell triggers the satellites (obligatory Escape from LA reference).

Jane

10.07.06 6:28 AM

Oh, I forgot, OmniFu would rock as a name.

Jane

10.07.06 6:29 AM

I am using Omni/Kinkless/GTD. I find it very effective. In omnifocus I would like to see some sort of due today list. Also, I think it would be useful to have the ability to group several projects into a single project goal as an afterthought. With GTD once you begin to gather the clutter of your life, you begin to realize that you may have several projects working towards a single goal. In kinkless you would have to manually group these projects.

Prem Mahtani

10.07.06 5:02 PM

One earlier commenter mentioned this software, but I think it deserved a repeating, since it's a good app that I'd be comparing any Omni GTD option against: ThinkingRock.

John

10.08.06 3:25 PM

I have tried Kinkless/OO but it's too inflexible for me.  So whatever you guys do, make sure its is very easy to switch (wit one or two clicks) from “collection mode” to project reviewing, to listing things by context, by project, by due date, by party you have delegated to, etc.


I have been using CircusPonies NoteBook for a few months now. One of the best productivity apps around.  I combine it with TypeIt4me to quickly create next actions/ waiting for/ project topics.  Keywords for contexts and some clever auto-sorts on pages do the rest.  Never more than 2 clicks (OK, sometimes a 3) away from every perspective that I need…

Only problem is that the data structure underlying every action item is a bit limited, and could do with an OO structure.


ThinkingRock has some good ideas in it, but its UI is not very attractive and it doesn't make much use of the OSX environment.  But the folks who wrote it have understood what GTD is all about (or at least they have understood the same thing I have :-)).


I would be happy to beta anything when you're ready!

Wim

10.09.06 7:33 AM

I agree with the following. Please don't re-invent the wheel. I'm sure with Omni's participation OmniFocus will be a winner. To get the GTD right, hire Ethan:


“I’m using kGTD and OmniOutlinerPro. I only bought OOP so I could run kGTD, so you Omni guys owe the kinkless huge thanks. It would be great if you would just place all the GTD stuff into the next version of OutlinerPro; it seems to work pretty well right now with kGTD, and a new app seems un-necessary, if OOP can be expanded. You already have most of the codebase written…”

James Lewis

10.09.06 10:23 AM

Must be able to use the outlines (projects, tasks by context, etc) from anywhere and any OS; so web-sync type functionality, two-way, would be a world-beater.  S.

Steven Hoy

10.10.06 8:26 AM

Would also be good to include dependencies.  Dependent tasks don't show up in the next actions list for whichever context applies until the dependency is completed.  S.

Steven Hoy

10.10.06 11:05 PM

I owned Omnioutliner before using kinkless. I like kinkless but would like to add a reality comment. I think that many of the people on this list are ubergeeks, in that doing something on the computer is better than doing it on paper.


I like using kGTD but that I still prefer using my paper based calendar and I really don't like having a pda. So I don't. Yet I am very technologically proficient, just don't like to use technology for everthing.


So as you develop your program, please bear in mind that not everyone is going to sync to ical or something or other. Please make it flexible enough to use without all the gee whiz technology or allow it to be flexible to use with a paper system. Thanks.

Steven Finder

10.11.06 3:04 AM

Please consider price or side/upgrade options carefully. Although OmniOutliner Pro is quite nice, I *only* bought it (and only use it) with KinklessGTD. So I've already spent quite a bit on this pre-OmniFocus setup and would rather not pay all over again.


That said, a polished OmniFocus.app will hopefully be hard to resist!

William Duckworth

10.11.06 3:35 AM

I just want to second (or third) the recommendation for a customized templated system. One of the real problems with a lot of the GTD systems is that I'm working constantly on the application rather than in the application. The ability to customize a template, allow it to be copied over with new project-specific information (based on some criteria such as date or name) is critical to making it all work. Omni has a great history with templates. I expect wonderful things! One last thing - it would be great if finished tasks could be styled as strikethrough (and not displayed when needed).

Andrew Boardman

10.11.06 3:13 PM

I'd like to see a second type of grouping which is similar to a project, except that the tasks can be done in parallel. Such a thing already exists in the !Single Tasks project, but it would be nice if we could have our own collections of parallel tasks. Even if it were just allowing sub'projects' of !Single Tasks which were parallel tasks would be OK.

Bill Rising

10.12.06 12:37 AM

A feature I've always wanted is to create tasks that are dependent on exteral tasks completing.


Meaining if I had two projects running, I could create a “next action” that would pause the current task until a “next action” in the other project completed.


This is very similar to dependent projects in Gnatt Charts.


Speaking of which… findinig ways to visualize data in different ways would be great!!


Last, two votes for OmniFocus!!!

ShaSpleen

10.13.06 10:23 AM

I currently use Microsoft Entourage's To-List, together with iCal and Missing Sync to keep my GTD stuff on both my Mac and my Treo.  I HATE Entourage, and it's making me very sloppy on GTD.


What I need is something that will:

a. Give me a way to sync with my Palm

b. Play with various email porgrams, since about 60-70% of my In items arrive via email.  Right now my employer's IMAP email is not playing so nicely with Mail.app, so I'm switching among Mail.app, Entourage, and Thunderbird, all of which, for me, have their problems.

c. A good linking system, so projects can point to next actions, and next actions can point to things that they might need, such as particular emails or documents.

Bob Sloan

10.13.06 3:33 PM

Making the “Sync” button automatic. So you don't have to think about clicking a sync button all the time. iCal should also be synced automatically.

Mattias

10.14.06 2:41 PM

Another vote for Yojimbo-style data collection. A major limitation of Yojimbo is that it only collects on-line stuff, and can't point to documents on your local drive. For OmniFocus to work well, it needs to be able to at least point to stuff out there and right here. Midnight Inbox does look good…but the thought of an Omni product to fill this void is making me hold out.

Tad Leckman

10.15.06 1:45 AM

[...] I’ve been using the Kinkless GTD system for Macintosh, which is a series of Applescripts added on to OmniOutliner Pro that enable me to plan projects step-by-step, but then view action lists by context, so all my calls are together, for instance. Ethan Schoonover (the developer of kGTD) and the Omni Group recently announced development of a new program called OmniFocus which will take what Ethan has hacked together and make elegant, like the other Omni apps. [...]

GTD Seminar on WebEx, and OmniFocus « Lines

10.15.06 8:25 AM

Looking forward to the product.  A real GTD app for Mac will be a life-changer.  I've been watching Midnight Beep's Inbox, and the thing I like that I see there is the ability to click immediately into collect,  process, organize and your reference section, and see everything from that perspective.  The more automated the process, the better.


The ideal future app to shoot for is one that knows what context I'm in, and presents only those options that I can work on in that context, from the total accumulated list of things I ought to be working on.  I should be able to click in and see more and make other choices, but I want to be able to glance up at a simple, elegant interface that shows what's next on my schedule, and what top selection of tasks I could be working on in the context I'm in.

Marc Schelske

10.16.06 3:49 PM

Wow… 200+ comments. I guess this will be a hit. Personally, I cannot wait.


BZ

BZ

10.17.06 11:23 PM

I'm a dedicated kGTD user as well. I'll buy an app if it's 3/4 as helpful as kGTD. Good name too, BTW.

Dennis

10.18.06 6:43 AM

AAAAAAAHHHHH, kGTD crippled the document again.. GRrrrrr..

Jacco

10.18.06 8:16 AM

[...] Fragen über Fragen. Die gut aussehenden Applikationen lassen leider noch auf sich warten. Vielversprechende Kandidaten sind Inbox und OmniFocus. [...]

1.4.all

10.19.06 7:26 AM

I am excited!  I just started using the GTD system and I'm using it with OmniOutliner (thinking of updating to OmniOutliner Pro and kGTD sometime soon) but the biggest thing I want is the ability to sync to PDAs/PDA Phones.  Either to some application native to the devices or some form of your application ported to the device.  I just want the portability.


Otherwise!  Awesome! I'm already a huge fan of OmniOutliner.

ryan Whitney

10.19.06 8:03 AM

Anyone know what's up with kinkless.com?  I just dusted off my mac and was very excited to pull it down and start noodling around with it.  But the site seems to be borked and I can't seem to find an alternative download source.


Any ideas?

Mad William Flint

10.19.06 12:46 PM

Email integration is a must. many of us receive a lot on info on Email and the integration of Email with GTD is a Key feature.

Marcos Detry

10.19.06 5:54 PM

[...] So, there’s a little app out there called OmniFocus, and I need it and I need it now. I’ve been using Kinkless for a while now and seeing the next logical step in it’s evolution just sounds awesome. [...]

Steve Wills Weblog » Blog Archive » I

10.22.06 12:58 AM

I have most OMNI group software (including OmniWeb) as family packs. I love the products. I also use the GTD system. However, I no longer use OmniOutliner for the GTD because the features were overwhelming and I couldn't take the time to learn kinkless. So now I use index card to capture ideas in the real world, iCal and Address Book to store dates and contacts, stickies and SERVICES-to NOTEBOOK to capture ideas while online, and NOTEBOOK to write all the Action Items and lists. However, if OmniFocus could be Very Specific to the GTD system, I'd purchase it in a heart beat. Like the iPod's design, make it less - - -  less is better (and that's why I am using NOTEBOOK right now). OmniGroup's software is still wonderful. Thanks

GTDuser432

10.22.06 9:51 AM

I have only just been introduced to the GTD system.  So far i have been using shadowplan.  Pretty good and lots of useful info from the net on how to use it.


My only concern, is i need it to sync to my palm, otherwise it's useless.

evielyn

10.22.06 11:17 PM

Lots of good suggestions here so far. However the name “OmniFocus” doesn't quite hit the mark, so do try to find a better one. Examples: OmniTask, OmniAct, OmniTrack, i.e. something concrete. Omni (everywhere) is the antithesis of Focus (one place and nowhere else), so find something that lets both words lean in the same direction.


I'm looking forward to trying out the app.

Fredritik Matheson

10.23.06 8:08 AM

I love OOP but kGTD just never worked ideally for me. I live and die by knowing what I need to do next.  Specifically, I like being able to have a “two minutes” list that can easily sync to my palm.  kGTD is great for organizing projects on my computer but it doesn't have good palm support. And, at 46 pounds, my G5 tower just isn't very portable!

andy

10.24.06 8:03 AM

I would just like to point out that the weak link in the current chain OOP + kGTD + iCal is iCal. I don't know how you're going to work your way around it. I am, in fact, considering going back to Entourage in order to avoid dealing with iCal. So please, as you move forward, remember that there is more than one calendaring app in Mac-land. I liked Kinkless very much. It was/is a great set of scripts, but I kept everything within kGTD because iCal was/is such a disaster.

John Laudun

10.24.06 12:29 PM

Definitely keep the data format fungible and open, so that integration with all sorts of ridiculous possibilities can open up.  If the end result is a GTD app that can roll like NetNewsWire and NewsGator sync and allow multiple clients hitting one info store, that's where I would find top value for the dollar.

Dallas H

10.25.06 2:33 AM

I currently use OOP + KGTD. I bought OOP because of GTD, but I know use for many other tasks. I find the task list in iCal a pain to work with, when I have a long list in it. The list view isn't worth of for me. I would love to see the possibility to sort by due date. Also, I don't follow David Allen in all manners, and I like to make a list of to do items for one day, which I create the day before preferably. I would love to have an expert function to html with an easy upload to my own website or synching with other sites (tada list comes to mind). Good connection with Quicksilver is a must for me. I literally use it all the time.

Niels Teunis

10.27.06 8:47 AM

I'm not a total GTD devotee, but it did persuade me that a clear and focused to do list would prove useful and it has done so. The one thing that most to do lists don't have though, which I'd absolutely love, is a very simple idea of projects comprised of various stages where only the next stage is displayed (along with perhaps an indicator of how many other stages there might be to come, as well as the ability to really easily add a new task or combination of tasks to any particular on-running project without it destroying me.


I'd also really like something for contexts - ie. the stuff that they say about things you can do in different places. For example, I'd absolutely love it if there was a way I could set a range of tasks to be done when I'm out and about that could be stuck onto my iPod, and some way of switching between contexts so I knew what jobs I had to do at home and which I was expecting to do at the office.


But the thing I'd love most, which I expect to be not enormously practical, given that I think the new version of Mail is going to have something like it is actually a way of browsing my incoming e-mail inside the GTD app. I need something that will let me either reply to an e-mail directly, or find some way of pulling it out into something I need to do from the e-mail (ie. either organise an event in iCal or Entourage) or turn it into a to do list or project - AND have the original e-mail attached to the thing in question so I can easily find it and reply to it when the task has been done or directly after capturing it.

Tom Coates

10.27.06 10:45 AM

please make it sync with the Nokia E61 via iCal.

UT

10.29.06 1:09 PM

Please name it OmniFu.

Nutrimentia

10.29.06 5:14 PM

Currently using:  Entourage, QuickSilver, and some Applescripts to implement GTD. 


I use Entourage categories as contextual task buckets (calls, home, office, errands, etc).  The task view is customized to show only Category, Task Name, Due Date.


I have an Applescript that triggers with a hotkey to mark project next actions as done.  The script marks the action as done and brings up the next next action for the project.  The script is at…


http://board.43folders.com/showthread.php?t=621&highlight=entourage


I use another AppleScript…


http://www.43folders.com/2005/06/14/quicksilver-applescript-to-quickly-add-entourage-tasks/


...to get new tasks into Entourage via a QuickSilver trigger.


Was considering a switch to kGTD, but I'll wait to see the outcome of this project before moving.

Supafly

10.29.06 5:53 PM

I'm another 'macs at home, windows at work' people. I need access to GTD data from everywhere. I currently don't use a PDA, so a web access, in addition to slick Mac client would be perfect.

Max

10.31.06 5:00 PM

allowing omnifocus to sync tasks directly to the palm woudl be a *HUGE* plus, since the iCal task syncing sucks, but it is the only way to interface Kinkless to my palm

chris brandow

11.01.06 6:37 AM

Currently using KGTD and OO PRO


Just make OmniFocus as clean and useable as your other programs!

Jerry K

11.01.06 8:40 AM

Like most people, currently using kGTD and OOP with LOTS of projects.  Here's what I need: the ability to temporarily prioritize tasks.  How about the ability to open a new window that is my current work period's “To-Do” list that I can click and drag tasks from my Project view into.  That way, if I'm in a place where I can only use my computer , I can grab any computer-related next actions from my projects list and put them into a streamlined view of what I can currently work on.

Branden

11.01.06 12:23 PM

the problem with many gtd software implementations is the lack of a calendar.  i need to see tasks sorted not only by context or project, but by date due.  and instead of just a list with dates, if i could see it in a graphic calendar that would be great.  also, dependent tasks and projects should have the option of being invisible until the right date, or until another task gets completed.

kiyong

11.03.06 9:35 AM

Considering sycning it to Basecamp projects with their API and also please considering tabs or sheets in a workbook where you can have different views or different sets of lists.

DL Byron

11.03.06 1:04 PM

I've recently started using Omni Outliner with Kinkless GTD. For personal self-organization and productivity, it's great. I've found it so useful that I've been going around to everyone on staff, one at a time, and getting them set up with it too. We'd love it even more, of course, if the Kinkless GTD functionality were built into Omni Outliner directly rather than through AppleScript. (Most of the time the AppleScript works fine, but there have been a few glitches.)


The main thing that missing for us is collaborative project planning. David Allen's Getting Things Done system is great for individuals, but as an organization we need to be able to share our project plans and status updates in a less detailed way. Since several members of our staff live in multiple geographical locations and rarely meet physically, being able to share this information easily via the internet is also important to us.


Currently we're using Google calendar and DotProject to handle most of our scheduling and planning. Google calendar works pretty well and lets us sync to iCal. DotProject has a clunky, cumbersome interface but at least lets us share our information via the web.


I downloaded and played around with Omni Plan briefly. I liked the overall look of the interface (Omni is great at that), but felt that it didn't quite meet our needs for group project planning. Here are a few specific criticisms:


(1) It seems to require users to create a separate document for each project. We would prefer to be able to create a single document that contains all of our projects.


(2) There's no way that I could see for us to publish and sync plans on the web. In order to share a plan collectively via the web, we'd have to be uploading/downloading the file or else emailing it around to everyone on staff, which would be cumbersome and confusing. I'd like a project planning system that approximates what we are able to do right now with Google Calendar:


* Each individual can have his own calendar. Only he can edit it, but it can also be shared on a read-only basis with others.


* We also have a group calendar that anyone on staff can edit.


* Using iCal we can subscribe to any of our Google calendars so that even if we're traveling and away from the internet, we're still able to access our schedules.


If OmniProject could make it possible to share Gantt charts and resource allocations in the same way that Google Calendar lets us share appointments and meeting info, we'd be much more interested in it.


Good luck with OmniFocus. We're rooting for you to succeed with a real killer app.

Sheldon Rampton

11.05.06 7:13 AM

I used kinkless w/OmniOutliner for a while but found it to be a little more cumbersome than I would like. Most important to me is that this new app be simple and intuitive to use.


Being able to sync lists to iPod would be a great feature.

Podophile

11.07.06 6:38 AM

How about a topic map representation of context and pending items with a calendering function as well.  If you want to get really wild add GPS functionality and RFID so your program can know where you are and what equiptment you have available.

Bldflw

11.15.06 11:25 AM

How about linking; person (address book ID) and communication (Mail ID) and time (iCal) and Project (OmniFocus) and visual timeline (Omni Plan). Looks heavy? Check out CRM4Mac and imagine added Leopard features.


More musings at http:/applepipsqueak.blogspot.com

Marc

11.16.06 9:15 AM

I'm amazed at some of the rather elaborate systems people use. Whatever works, but I found the only way to get GTD to remotely work for me was to keep it simple. Otherwise I spend too much time on the system, not enough on getting stuff done, and I also resisted doing reviews with a more elaborate system. And time is waaay too precious to spend fiddling with a GTD system. We all have lives to live.


I am using a Moleskine 16-month calendar to list my project notes, to-dos, and appointments and index cards for capture when away from the desk. I use Address Book and my Palm for contacts. This works okay for me—it's simple and there's not lots of “playing” with the system, which is a Very Good Thing.


But my system does have shortcomings: I'd like a way to tie projects and contexts closer together, and to have more room for Project notes (not a lot of room for this in the Moleskine calendar). I also like having alerts, which isn't possible with paper.


So I'm mildly interested to see how OmniFocus works. But I'm not interested in tons of cool geegaws: I want real simplicity to set up my projects and contexts, and I want simplicity to export it to the real world, either by printing to cards I can keep in my Moleskine or by syncing to my Palm.


I tried Kinkless, but I couldn't get it to work with the trial version of OOPro and I gave up. Another friend tried it and eventually ran into problems keeping it synched.  I love the idea of Kinkless, though, and think Ethan is brilliant, but I do think OmniFocus needs to be very simple to set up and maintain. Be kind to those of us who are not highly capable geeks, please.


I don't like iCal for one reason—the task list is hard to read, you can't adjust the formatting of it.

If OmniFocus didn't loom, and and I went full-steam back to an electronic solution, I'd use Entourage. People love to complain about Entourage, and it's not perfect, but it has a lot more muscle than Mail+iCal and I love that you can tie mail, notes, to-dos together. This forming of instant connections is what I miss most in using a paper solution instead of a computer-based one. It is particularly useful to someone like me who is self-employed and has no one to delegate to.


So I hope that OmniFocus will:

—be simple for a non-geek to set up and maintain

—can sync with Entourage (which should mean in turn I could sync with a Treo, which I plan to buy within the next year). (If it only synced with iCal, that would be okay, as long as I didn't have to look at that iCal task list)

—have an easy means to print to index cards


I wish you all the best with OmniFocus and hope that my comments are helpful.

Jeff

11.18.06 3:32 AM

Omni,


Here are some of the items on my OmnniFocus wishlist.  Do you have any tentative dates yet for a beta?


- [ ] Application Integration:  OmniFocus could integrate well with

    iCal (adding “to do items,” scheduling events, and Calendar

    grouping)

  - [ ] Integration with other OmniApplications is a must.  For

      example,

      - [ ] Send Context Specific Action Items to OmniPlan.

  - [ ] Growl Integration for notifications.

  - [ ] AddressBook Integration

  - [ ] Mail Integration (send email from within OmniFocus.

  - [ ] Full Integration with OS X Services

  - [ ] Fully Spotlight searchable in each Object and Module of the

      application:  Projects, Contacts, Action Items, Resources,

      Calendar.

- [ ] Import-Export:  Is there any chance of being able to import the

    tasks from our current kGTD/OO files?

  - [ ] Import data from OmniOutliner into Action Items.

  - [ ] Export plans to OmniOutliner

  - [ ] Export data to OmniGraffle to build flow charts.

- [ ] Syncing:  iSync with .Mac like Kinkless currently does as well as

    syncing with Palm.

- [ ] Web Accessible:  OmniFocus could be â??ubiquitousâ?? usable on the

    web and on the Mac (and maybe with a mobile device).  and it

    would really establish a new standard in GTD productivity.

- [ ] Scriptable:  I have but one feature request for OmniFocus:

    pleasepleaseplease make it scriptable. Very, very scriptable.

- [ ] Completely Customizable:  Ability to customize and group Project,

    Goal, Action Item, Start Date, End Date, Milestones, categories

    and details.  Also with the ability to group (customizable list)

    projects by Work, Home, Other, etc.

  - [ ] Categorize Action Items:  Ability to Sort, Filter, and

      categorize Action Items chronologically and categorically

      (all categories).  (as suggested by 43folders).

- [ ] Contextual Linking:  Create Contextual links between related

    Objects, Action Items, Projects, Resources, and Contacts in the

    application.  Link Action items shared by multiple projects,

    resources shared by multiple projects, Action Items associated

    with multiple Contacts,

- [ ] Full Drag & Drop Functionality:  It should be really easy to link

    these to a project (and also every task connected to that

    project). Like dragging and dropping the reference files on the

    project name in a list or similar.

- [ ] Data Tracking & Reporting:  At least a few stock reports, but

    with a “Report Builder” that allows users to customize their own

    reports querying any combination of data fields in the

    application.

  - [ ] Automated Reviews-Reports:  Reviews of progress against

      Projects, Goals, Action Items, Deadlines, etc. with Visual

      and data representations of progress.

      - [ ] Daily:  As a whole, by Project, By Goal, By Action Items,

          By Contacts, By Deadlines, By time spent on per Project,

          Per Goal, Per Action Item, Per Contact

      - [ ] Weekly:  As a whole, by Project, By Goal, By Action

          Items, By Contacts, By Deadlines; By time spent on per

          Project, Per Goal, Per Action Item, Per Contact

      - [ ] Monthly:  As a whole, by Project, By Goal, By Action

          Items, By Contacts, By Deadlines; By time spent on per

          Project, Per Goal, Per Action Item, Per Contact

      - [ ] Quarterly:  As a whole, by Project, By Goal, By Action

          Items, By Contacts, By Deadlines; By time spent on per

          Project, Per Goal, Per Action Item, Per Contact

      - [ ] Yearly:  As a whole, by Project, By Goal, By Action

          Items, By Contacts, By Deadlines; By time spent on per

          Project, Per Goal, Per Action Item, Per Contact

      - [ ] Lifetime:  As a whole, by Project, By Goal, By Action

          Items, By Contacts, By Deadlines; By time spent on per

          Project, Per Goal, Per Action Item, Per Contact

- [ ] Cross-Platform Information Sharing:  Compatibility with Multiple

    File Resource File Types:  Ability to link to Resource Documents

    in a variety of file types:  HTML, XHTML, MS Word, MS Excel,

    PowerPoint, Open Document:  ODT, ODP, ODS, Keynote, Pages, Plain

    Text, RTF, OmniOutliner, OPML, OmniGraffle, OmniPlan, QuickTime,

    PDF, AAC, MP3, NovaMind.

- [ ] Action Item Timer:  Start & Stop Timer for Action Items that need

    quick attention, and for long term tracking of Time Management

    Performance.

- [ ] Resource Library:  As the user links resources to Projects,

    Contacts, Goals, Action Items, Deadlines, etc. have the

    application record the links in a central Library that can be

    further categorized by Resource Type, Usage Context, (perhaps

    other customizable categories) so that they can be easily

    accessed and re-used when needed.

John Sheppard

11.20.06 2:36 AM

I wish there was more integration between Mail and everything else. I want to be able to send a piece of mail and schedule a follow-up and note whether I am supposed to do something or the other person is supposed to do something. I want the text of the email, the From/To, the date, the priority, etc. I've considered embedding little codes in my email and then filtering the email and posting events to iCal. But then I saw Leopard Mail had (maybe) what I need.

Martin Streicher

11.21.06 2:18 AM

Tags.  Plain and simple.  I used to use Notebook from CircusPoines, because you could assign keywords (tags) to items.  like a @Calls tag, or a @WaitingOn tag, and then you could view everything by tag.  Make it really quick and easy to do that (maybe even with a keyboard shortcut) and I'll be happy.


Oh, and make it realy easy to put things in the inbox from anywhere.

Doug

11.21.06 7:03 AM

Please let it sync with the blackberry for task syncing or via pocketmac cheers JP

John Paul Fizpatrick

11.27.06 12:56 AM

I Would love to be able to make use of my desktop. My background wallpaper is coolas, but I think its a waste of space! It would be amazing if this App could display or become the desktop. I have all my icons small and ordered down one columnm on the right. I would love to be able to use the rest of the space for the visibility and planning of my time, projects and tasks. In otherwords, If this App Works through the OSx Desktop- it would be the tits.

Lozz Kitson

11.27.06 8:53 AM

If I can merely put it into “action item” mode to use in conjunction with OmniPlan tasks, life will be sweet.

TwiceAsMuchGlassAsYouNeed

11.30.06 3:44 PM

I have just started playing with kGTD, I use my Treo 650's task list as both my list of next actions and an “inbox”. I use mail.app with mailtags, and I use gmail with stars and tags. And I restart my GTD once every 6 months because 4 months is about as long as I can keep it going to date. Maybe OmniFocus will fix that :) When's the beta?

Carson

12.01.06 6:28 AM

[...] Har utvärderat diverse GTD-apps jag hittat via 43 Folders, men ännu inte hittat något jag föredrar över penna och pappar. Väntar på att kunna testa OmniFocus… [...]

Program för att organisera sig - 99mac

12.02.06 3:57 AM

I am currently using Frictionless. I found this page by clicking a link from this article (http://lowendmac.com/eubanks/06/1004.html). I really like the color coding of “next action”, “due”, “done”, etc. I think the addition of some type of separate notes tab might be cool that arent necessarily associated with individual tasks or projects (but maybe could be if you so desire). I currently open up a text edit document to review roles and someday maybes such as (gifts etc. my wife likes that I may want to pick up for her as a surpise this week or articles that I really want to read but don't want to make a task until I have a slower week yet don't want to forget about) It would be nice to have it integrated into a omnifocus system just for consolidation purposes. Also, a mind mapping feature would be cool in order to develope ideas to flesh out actions. Just things that I would use and get excited about. Can't wait till Omnifocus is available!

Christian

12.06.06 5:17 AM

Not sure if this was already mentioned, but it would be helpful to be able to include longer term projects/commitments, i.e. one year, five year; or the 10k level, 20k level . . . 50k level. 

I am currently using kinkless for discrete tasks and iCal for the hard landscape (though I'm undisciplined and priorities shift during the day).  One gap I've noticed is that in kinkless I'm focused on the immediate tasks and don't incorporate long term or higher level planning. 

The ability to capture those thoughts in a meaningful and accessible way would be incredibly helpful for me.  (By accessible I mean organized in a way that makes more sense. I realize now that I should create a project in kinkless for one year and five year and set start/end dates and have it reset or recur on a regular basis so it pops up when periodically.  Something like that but more elegant and better thought out would be neat.)

d

12.07.06 3:41 PM

I'm pretty new to the whole deal, but I'm using a varied system (on mac) that doesn't really do what I want it to completely yet. Tracks for project/next actions. Remind+geektool for ticklers. Tkremind for calendar (and then the printout serves as an inbox).


I suppose if you followed all the wish lists here, you'd wind up with a new operating system, and perhaps hardware. (Seriously, GPS?) My one wish, and one that I can't find in ANY of the applications is project threading.


I map a project out either by hand or in my head (in much the same way as mind-mapping software) but it can be condensed into a threaded outline, where some things depend on other things, but other bits can go on in parallel. I think it's even one of the examples in the Bib^H^H^H GTD book.


Part of a project that depends on the previous action to be done before it can be done SHOULDN'T be on the next action list. If you're waiting for the W-4 to come before you can do your taxes, it's only a distraction for “Do Taxes” to show up on the next action list. In fact, it's contrary to the whole idea of putting things out of your mind until you can do them.


If someone knows of, or writes, software that can wait until I check off “waiting for W-4” to put “Do Taxes” on the next action list before I get around to adding it to Tracks gets my hearty congratulations and/or Loonies.

Pat

12.08.06 2:19 PM

Many of the previous comments echo my needs and desires.  I was using EasyTask, but have just switched (am trying) to kGTD/OO.  One very strong comment I can make is please provide a zoom feature.  I find my eyes are having more trouble each year reading OO.  I don't want to increase the font size, just want to be able to zoom in so I can read the text.  Something like command-+ in mail.


Well, since I'm at it, I might as well include the other number one needs:

1)  iCal integration.  kGTD comes the closest the I've seem.  But I'd like to have both todos as well as events covered. 

2)  Mac Mail - so much of my new tasks come in via email.  Again, kGTD does it, and Inbox does it especially well; kGTD with help from other scipts lets me send emails into OO - I think that's fine.  I had thought Inbox's way of automatically pulling email into it was nifty, but after using both systems awhile, I'm of the opinion now that pushing (sending from mail) is better than pulling (like Inbox), because I'd rather filter the mail in the mail app.

pvonk

12.09.06 12:41 PM

[...] Nothing against GTD - it works for a lot of people and I’ve heard great things about Kinkless GTD. We should expect Omnifocus to be another solid app to come from the Omni guys. The point to consider though is that GTD has become a veritable religion when it should be thought of as a best practices framework of behaviors from which you develop your own system. Learn it but then synthesize it, chop it up and take the aspects you like piecemeal from it and other systems to create your own style. In the end it’s not how closely you can conform to orthodox GTD, it’s about how much you can accomplish while reducing stress and elimating the “open loops”. I moderated a discussion yesterday on project management with Trac at the first ever Barcamp in Phoenix. If we get the video capture from that session, I’ll post it here in the comment field.  Pass it along:These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages. [...]

Scrollin’ On Dubs » Blog Archive &raqu

12.10.06 6:59 AM

Linda, I'm using kGTD and omnioutliner pro, and indeed bought your product because of kGTD. I hope Ethan's helping you guys!

steve

12.10.06 11:44 PM

One other suggestion, on top of my previous ones, is OmniFocus' GUI.  I currently use kGTD after having used EasyTask and ThinkingRock and looking at Inbox.  I must say that I think using a OO interface is a real kluge.  Now, I use OO for outlining courses and other tasks, but I find the OO interface for GTD is way too primitive and, how shall I put it, not graphically compelling or pleasing.


Please consder an interface that is appropriate for a GTD app - something like EasyTask, for example.

pvonk

12.11.06 5:15 AM

[...] Oh, and by the way, did I mention that I am getting a MacBook Pro when Leopard ships next year. What then? kGTD, Midnight Inbox, or the upcoming OmniFocus!?!?! [...]

Black Belt Productivity » Tools, When is Eno

12.11.06 4:06 PM

iCal sync- Native

Palm sync - NATIVE (MUST)


Please hurry up, the natives are about to jump ship.

Dr. J

12.12.06 8:41 AM

[...] Tools, When is Enough?.Enough? December 12th, 2006 by Michael Ramm   By definition, a tool is is a piece of equipment that most commonly provides a mechanical advantage in accomplishing a physical task. [1] As I was looking through my latest pr0n mag (or as it is better known, the Levenger Last Minute Shopping 2006 mag), I was drooling over a number of items contained within. On every page I was thinking of how could I incorporate item X into my current system; thinking that the Circa Starter Kit is so reasonably priced…how could I NOT get it! We all have our own tools for GTD. Currently, my main tool is a Moleskine Softcover 2007 LARGE Weekly Planner+Notebook (as seen in the header picture above). I really like it a lot, but I am not using it the way that intended to last September when I bought it. I had planned on using it as my hard landscape [calendar] and the planning pages on the right side would hold my weekly NAs that I wanted to accomplish that week. Well, most of the planning pages between September 1 and today are pretty blank. Another tool that I have is Evernote 1.5. It is a pretty nifty notetaking program and I wanted to use it as Project/Reference Support Material holder. Again, most of the program is empty. I do have some project set up in it, as well as some reference lists, and conference materials that I want to trigger me to look into at a later date. I would love to be able to incorporate Mindjet’s MindManager into my stable. I see that other’s have successfully done it and never looked back. I have never used mindmapping before, so I read up on it a little, and thought that it looked like an interesting approach to thinking. Now being in IT, there is not a lot of use for creative expression and free thinking that is MindManager’s strong suit. I even printed out the manual to learn how to effectively use the program, but have yet to read it. Now, with Windows Vista and Outlook 2007 on the horizon there are great improvements on the basic tools that come with a computer that will make GTD a lot simpler for Windows users. The Outlook team specifically looked at GTD when they were designing the new refinements to To Do’s in Outlook 2007. And the new built in Calendar in Vista will be able to be published to an iCal compliant calendar, like Google Calendar. Oh, and by the way, did I mention that I am getting a MacBook Pro when Leopard ships next year. What then? kGTD, Midnight Inbox, or the upcoming OmniFocus!?!?! Then I glance over next to the monitor that I am looking at to right this out and see my very first GTD tool: an HP iPAQ hx4700 with Pocket Informant preloaded on it. I paid over $600 for that PDA and accessories, and you know what it does now….sits on my desk as a glorified calendar and slide show of pictures of my kids. I really loved that PDA and when I left my last job in Jan 2006, I left the joys of Microsoft Exchange and Outlook. Now that I am the boss and Exchange will be making a appearance sometime in FY 2007, I may revisit the use of my PDA and Outlook. But that does not help me now. I think that we get wrapped up in the Tools of GTD, and not the methodology of GTD. Between now and the end of the year, I am going back to basics. I am going to listen to the GTD Fast compilation and let what David Allen is talking about really sink in to my bones. Then I will follow that up with another read of Getting Things Done. Every time that I have read GTD the book, I have come away with some tidbit that makes the whole thing make more sense to me. If what David Allen states is true (about 5:25 minutes into the podcast), and that it takes 2 years for GTD to really sink in, than I am about 3 1/2 months from a HUGE breakthrough. And I want to be ready for it when it happens. - Michael [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tools [...]

Kolz Blog » Blog Archive » Tools, When

12.12.06 2:50 PM

[...] It’d be great to also see bundles targeted at specific niches. For example, a bundle for productivity-junkies might include Hazel, OmniFocus, and FlexTime. For designers, I’d like to see a package with apps like CSSEdit, OmniGraffle, and GraphicConverter X. [...]

Get 10 insanely great Mac apps for under 50 bucks

12.13.06 1:43 PM

[...] What is Getting Things Done (GTD)? From the owner’s website, GTD is “work-life management system and book by David Allen that transforms personal overwhelm and overload into an integrated system of stress-free productivity.” It has a few basic core values, including collecting everything that has your attention, organizing it all according to how and when you need to accomplish it, and defining concrete actions, and constantly reviewing it against your goals. Well, that’s a pretty bad description. Learn more here. I’m not all-knowing as to GTD’s process, but I’ve started a long process of implementing some of it’s key tenets, and I generally like the approach. Anyway, you get the idea. So there are several ways to use technology to implement the principles of GTD. Nobody covers GTD on the Mac better than Merlin Mann over at 43 folders his blog focused on personal productivity and related issues. One of those ways is to use OmniOutliner from the Omni Group, and a set of Applescripts. Another is to use a new application called Actiontastic. It’s even possible to use Apple’s Mail.app and other of Apple’s programs. I have started using Mail by transforming it from a file storage and browser app to more of a To Do List (which will be easier when Leopard launches), and I use something called LifeBalance (ugghh, cheesy name!) to manage tasks around my goals. Recently, Omni pre-announced a product called OmniFocus that is expected to be a rich GTD application. And if it’s like most of Omni’s applications for Mac OS X, it will be pretty darn good. I’ve got my hopes up. But I’ve got two key requirements that are darn near non-negotiable. [...]

Friday Software Spotlight: OmniFocus » Apple

12.14.06 8:07 AM

[...] It’s an exciting time for Mac-using GTDers. Not only is Actiontastic coming along very nicely, but the Omni Group, makers of such excellent Mac apps as OmniOutliner, OmniGraffle, and OmniWeb, have announced that they’re also developing a stand-alone GTD application for Mac OS X. It’s sure to be a very professional and polished piece of work. [...]

Podophile » Blog Archive » Getting Thi

12.20.06 6:58 AM

I've given up on OmniOutliner/KGTD and iCal synching. It's all too much, and all the button-pushing, blech. I am pretty much using projects and categories in MS Entourage for Mac OS X to manage the active stuff, and Outliner to handle my Someday/Maybe and Archive crap so I can easily review information and find things when I want them.


But, if I could have a project manager that did all my GTD organizing in one place and synched with Entourage, I would be so very, very happy. I feel so terribly discombobulated all the time, and I'm *thisclose* to going to a paper-based system (*shudder*).

eric

12.20.06 10:00 PM

I use iCal/kGTD/Treo 650. iCal syncing is a must! Context to Calendars is prefered. And some work should go into ensuring the way that when mobile device sync with iCal the proper tasks get precedence. Nothings worse than finishing a bunch of task to just have them reappear.

Steve

12.21.06 1:56 AM

And by the way, could you deliver all of the things we're asking for by next Tuesday? ;) The Omni team has shown me repeatedly that y'all know what you're doing, so you don't need my advice. I'll give it anyway. Take your time, get it right, and you'll have a *major* hit on your hands.

Erik

12.22.06 4:43 AM

It definitely needs to allow viewing/synching with my Blackberry (8700c)

Paul

12.22.06 2:58 PM

[...] OmniFocus (is it ready yet? [...]

Best Tool For the Job » A Year of Shareware

12.25.06 9:56 AM

GTD is about governing the junk: In no more than two minutes per email, voice mail or paper chunk delete it, do it, delegate it or defer it.


VM and paper are out of scope, therefore. That leaves (1) email, including attachments, (2) self-inflicted URLs and files and (3) thoughts.


(1) the email client can deal with do or delete; OF just needs to handle defer, including follow-up on delegated email.


(2) OF shouldn't try to be a single app to rule them all—action not archives


(3) that leaves paragraph length thoughts, an ability to tag by project, context, associated person and perhaps a few user definable tags and associate a timeframe to dump the thought into the inbox for reconsideration as an action


By these lights, OF ends up as a tagable front-end to the UNIX at command. Simpler is harder but Omni seems good at that.

Richard

12.25.06 3:48 PM

Include my vote for the following:

1. Good integration with todos in iCal (which will then allow easy synching with Palm etc.)

2. easy command line (or at least AppleScript support so we can do this ourself) access via Quicksilver for easy addition of items

3. a reasonable price (student discount?)

Muninn

12.28.06 3:29 PM

I have tried various programs, but have come back to using OmniOutliner as a simple way of organising my projects.  I tried Kinkless, but it messed up my document and made it unusable.  I have also tried FileMaker but it seems too complex for my (rather simple) needs.  So, OmniOutliner it is for the present, with just a few categories (Important, less important, today, tomorrow, next week, etc).  I look forward to trying out your product.

Brian

01.04.07 7:57 AM

Can you tell us a release date ?

Marc

01.05.07 1:48 AM

[...] The Omni Group, who I love, are working on some kind of widget for doing this stuff called OmniFocus. If its like their usual stuff, it’ll rock. But I do hope they recognise users like me, who probably only occasionally need it, and so don’t want to invest a huge (or even small) amount of time in setup - this is why I like OmniOutliner and gtodo - you can go from nothing to a useful list in about 30 seconds flat. [...]

Links » To Do Lists

01.06.07 10:31 PM

Was using Daylite but dumped it before the trial expired, I felt is was overly complex. I also have life balance which is a little simple.

Am now starting to use OO with Kinless. So far, it appears to be the best approach but still in initial learning.

I'd like to be able to drag and drop emails ala Outlook to turn them into tasks, big win for me.

I'd also like to be able to print in the Franklin planner format which is what I tend to carry around with me at work.

Christopher

01.07.07 1:40 PM

I know this isn't quite GTD, but I would like support for recurring tasks (seems like whenever I go into collection mode, I start giving myself reminders about recurring tasks I always forget about, and then I have no idea how to process them in GTD).  Also, projects that have multiple tasks in them - I'd like to make dependency maps.  like a directed graph, where a node can have both multiple parents (I have to do both parents before I'm enabled to do the node) and multiple children (after I do the node, I am them enabled to do these multiple tasks).

Curt

01.07.07 5:54 PM

I've been through the wringer since learning about GTD a few years ago and trying to integrate it on my Mac/Treo setup. After trying Daylite, EasyTask, LifeBalance, iCal, MarkSpace, Devon products, Omni products, you name it, I've come, just this week, full circle back to Now Up-to-Date.


I haven't quite figured out how to manage the projects in it yet, but I'm working on using undated events. Now is the ONLY program I have found that does repeating to-do's that have the flexibility I need. Many (Daylite, iCal, etc.) do not even support repeating to-dos.


As others have written, over half of my tasks actually are regularly repeating things, and I'm baffled that so many programs ignore this. Daylite, for example has been promising to implement this for about three years now. iCal CAN support this, but Apple hasn't implemented it.


So, for me, repeating to-do's integrated with GTD next action philosophy, syncing with my Treo, etc.

AlisonMooreSmith

01.13.07 6:22 PM

I'm rather old fashion. I currently have a little pocket calendar that I jot down what I need to do on each day and what I accomplished. That way I can tell when I have appointments, and when I look back I can tell if I am getting enough done. If I am not I can work to improve. It's pretty basic but it just works for me.

Mark Watson

01.17.07 2:17 AM

I am currently using the Kinkless GTD/Omni Outline combination for my basic tasks, and a spreadsheet for my longer-term goals. I would like to see an app that can track long-term goals and how they releate to my values and whether I am on track or not. It would also show goals that were not met or abandoned and allow for a reason why.


Goals can be assigned types such as experience, knowledge, skill, acheivement, personal development, pocession / thing ownership, and relation.


I have tried all sort of apps on Macs and PCs and still haven't found what I am looking for. Franklin Covey's software has some nice features with Mission Statements and values.

Steve Robertson

01.17.07 7:15 AM

I'm currently using OmniFocus 3.23 with my Apple iPhone Tablet - it's like butta. Things were a little rough through 'Focus 1.0, 1.3 etc. but stabilized right about 2.1.

But then, I'm from the future.

Ron

01.23.07 11:23 PM

The most important feature is seamless syncing with PDAs (in my case a PocketPC device) that have advanced PIMs installed like Agendus and Pocket Informant. What good is a system on my Mac if when sycing between my PDA some metainfo gets lost, like categories or extra fields in a contact.

Whatever you do make it sync with Pocket Informant and or Agendus via iSync and the Missing Sync in a way that keeps extra functionality on my PDA like not only recurring tasks but also tasks that repeat themselves only after being checked of (as in life balance).

 

Marcel

01.24.07 4:22 AM

New to gtd. Using Kinkless, but it seems to be flakey and at this point I am hooked on gtd and don't have a tool to help me.


I am desperate for a tool. Please keep me informed. I have OO Pro on 2 Macs. I would be happy to Beta as long as the data file can be recreated in the event of problems.


HELP!

Nick Pappas

01.29.07 1:03 AM

Hi, I'm currently using kGTD/iCal/Agendus Pro.  Have been for some time, and almost patiently waiting for OmniFu, er Focus to arrive.  I'd be happy to help with the beta, BTW.  For me syncing with the palm in both directions would be a real plus.  kGTD got me hooked on using Omni Outliner.  And so I'm waiting and wondering what's next and how things are progressing.  Thanks for all your efforts so far.

Jaime Cobb

01.29.07 1:57 PM

If OmniFocus has a nice way to include task dependencies, I will buy it on Day 1.


I do like Curt's idea of a directed graph or dependency map, but even without that (desireable) level of complexity, I consider handling task dependencies well to be a make-or-break feature for me. I tend to have a fairly large number of varyingly dependent activities in flight, and I need some way of cutting through the clutter.


I am a current user of Thinking Rock, which I like, but which currently requires what I supply ugly kludges to deal with task dependencies.


I have used MS Project, which is, of course, all about dependencies, but there are so many other drawbacks (eg., can't shrink the text to be able to see more tasks on a screen) that I would much rather go with something that helps me, rather than fights me.


BTW, I have used OmniOutliner, and so I am a general fan of your products, and am assuming that OmniFocus will have the same high standards.


Note: I currently have no need to sync it with a PDA, but would like to sync across computers (mac Laptop and Desktop), as well as a PC Laptop at work. Just a data point for you…

JimG

01.30.07 9:43 AM

Switched to Mac in Nov 06 after 20 years of DOS/Windows machines.

Discovered kGTD a few days ago and liked what I saw enough to upgrade from the bundled OO to OOPro.

WANT?

1. The functionality I had with the old DOS based Lotus Agenda (yes, I date myself) or Net Manages Ecco Pro. 

Specifically, pull in contacts too.  Tasks, Projects, Contacts all linked.

ADVICE: take a look at Crm4Mac (http://www.crm4mac.com)- I bought it so I could link contacts to projects…..can also link in docs.  Also automatically links email to contacts.  Not well documented, but by right clicking a contact name can filter and view all to dos, emails, etc related to a contact.

Good luck…I'll buy.

jmg

John Gilreath

02.02.07 4:07 AM

[...] Now, that was mean, I admit. For the people that are not so into GTD, or productivity, OmniFocus is one of the most hyped GTD applications for Mac OS, and ThinkingRock is a Java application that closely follows the GTD methodology. And being Java is cross-platform, obviously. OmniFocus is not launched yet, but has had is share of buzzwords allready. [...]

eDragonu - the choice of a personal path » M

02.05.07 11:42 PM

Is there a release date for this yet, I'll probably buy it!

Chris

02.06.07 7:27 AM

[...] Starting from hyped application that doesn’t yet exists, like OmniFocus, to recently strategically planned online apps, like Stikkit, which succesfully embarked Merlin Mann from the famous 43folders.com in their advisor’s staff. I think that was, from a PR viewpoint, an extremely good move, and I know for sure that the guys from Omni had the opportunity to do the same. Merlin politely stated that his support for OmniFocus is pro-bono, but the real thing is that his consulting services are a real gem. I mean, not only by their objective value, which I really doubt that can be challenged, but by the visibility and endorsment they could get by offically having Merlin in their team. That would gave them a huge advantage. From what I saw, Merlin took his advisor work very seriously (which I always knew he would) and gave us some insights, the stikkit thing looks pretty promising. [...]

eDragonu - the choice of a personal path » L

02.08.07 8:44 AM

I use an OmniOutliner Pro file with extra columns for “do date”, “priority”, and “links”—the first two are sort keys. The links are to folders, to files, and to other outlines. I use color to distinguish weekend / weekday items, and to highlight “next” tasks.


This works extremely well, except for one thing: I'd really really love it if I could keep things in sync with my Palm PDA and my future Treo.


For assorted bits of info, I use Yojimbo, which works very well, and syncs via .mac, BUT same problem: no Palm syncing.


If OmniOutliner could incorporate easy management of bits of data, with filters so I can see things by context, and if it would easily sync with Palm and via .mac, I'd be totally happy. If the only way I can get those features is through OmniFocus, so be it. But I've got to have them!

Henri Picciotto

02.09.07 4:23 PM

[...] kGTD ha recibido la afección de muchas personas, incluyendo Merlin Mann, quien ha escrito varios artículos sobre kGTD, y ha inspirado el Grupo Omni para construir OmniFocus. KinklessGTD todavía contiene varios errores, pero parece que Ethan no va a hacer una versión nueva, por que aparentemente trabaja ahora en OmniFocus. Puede ser que la versión actual — 0.83 — seria la ultima, que es suficiente para algunas personas, pero no para todas. KinklessGTD está disponible gratuita y libre bajo una licencia GNU, aunque requiere la compra de OmniOutliner Pro para $70. [...]

KinklessGTD — El Canasto

02.10.07 11:14 PM

- Mail plug-in to shoot a link to an email back to OmniFocus (collect)  (how about being able to read the email right from OmniFocus too)

- Safari/Firefox plug-in to send a URL to OmniFocus (colllect)

- Finder plug-in (send file to OmniFocus or simply link to it))

- Scanner support or link to a folder (folder action) so that when a scan arrives it imports into OmniFocus.  Item can later be dragged out, printed, etc.

- In fact, you could probably allow a user to define other folders as well- when content gets dropped in, it automatically shoots it into OmniFocus- Hmmm, combined with Hazel, could be pretty powerful.

- I think trying to define projects in next actions titles that end up syncing to iCal would be too messy given iCal's limited interface.  I would either avoid projects definition as far as it relates to iCal sync or come up with a project “short tag” that could be appened to the beginning of the next action when syncing with iCal.

- how about throwing us a bone like 1st half of 07, 2nd half of 07?  :o)


Thanks much!

James

02.11.07 12:38 PM

I'm using kGTD+iCal, and while it's great and all (the best I've found), I don't find that the GTD method is perfect for me.  It would be if my work was ever finished.  As it stands, I have to prioritize a bit.


To this effect, I'd really like to be able to assign “time” as well as “date” to actions.  If this were possible, the logical next step would be syncing with iCal EVENTS rather than TO-DOs.  I desperately want to be able to organize my actions in something like kGTD, but view them and reorganize them in a realistic linear way, like iCal events.  This would be the kicker for me.  If not implemented, I'll just keep looking.

THANKS!!

 

bif

02.12.07 8:50 AM

[...] of course, OmniFocus, when it will be launched [...]

eDragonu - the choice of a personal path » &

02.13.07 9:26 PM

For more information about our release schedule and other common questions, see the OmniFocus pre-pre-pre-release information page:


http://www.omnigroup.com/applications/omnifocus/


We plan to ship a public beta release (at least) in the first half of 2007.

Ken

02.14.07 1:36 PM

„Thoughts about the Hyrum Smith/Stephen Covey “top down” approach to planning, and the David Allen “bottom up” school.


The pure Getting Things Done (GTD) system seems to have some weaknesses. The first one is that it tends to stress urgency over importance. If something needs to be done, there's no real difference in the system between one thing and the next. Allen says that the user should rely on intuition to pick what the real priority is out of the list. More often than not, I'll pick anything but “clean up the living room” out of my @Home context, even if I know that's what really needs doing the most. I may be “getting things done,” but am I getting the right things done? Covey says that the difference between efficiency and effectiveness is doing things right versus doing the right things. The GTD system doesn't really enforce effectiveness.


Part of the reason for that is that GTD also has no obvious connection to the user's core values. As expected in a “bottom up” approach, it's focused more on getting the daily minutae out of your mind so you can think about other things. This is great, but once you've got that under control, how do you know what to think about? And how do you know what's really most important to do at any given time?


That's not to say that the Franklin/Covey system of planning is any better, just different. Covey's “big rocks” system has its own flaws and weaknesses. For one, it's not context focused, so you're often reminded to do things when you can't possibly do anything about them. Two, it tends to let the smaller, lower-priority stuff fall through the cracks. How many people with Franklin Planners have had the same C priority stuff at the bottom of the list for weeks or months, with no progress on them at all?


No, to be truly effective, I need a mixture of Allen's “bottom up” planning and Covey's “top down” visioning. And that's where Life Balance developed by LlamaGraphics comes in.

Life Balance has an interesting philosophy. On the one hand it encourages you to do high level visioning and hierarchical planning, but on the other hand it's extremely context-focused and gives you simple, uncluttered lists of what really needs to be done.


How does it do this? There are four main parts of the program, accessed via an icon bar at the top of the screen. The first is Outline. This is a pretty standard hierarchical planning system at first glance, allowing you to break large projects down into manageable steps. But the magic is in the details, and there are subtle nuances to Life Balance that make it different from anything else on the market. For each item in the outline, you can select a level of importance. This has nothing to do with due dates. Importance is not urgency. You select how important this item is to its parent, on a sliding scale ranging from Essential to Somewhat, all the way down to None. You don't have to worry about how important a task is relative to other tasks, just to the parent. Tasks are sorted against each other by sophisticated algorhythms that factor in relative and cumulative importance as well as urgency and context.“


(See whole text at http://www.writingonyourpalm.net/column040202.htm)


I just started to use GTD-Software and I noticed it´s most important to have the system available erverywhere (which means it has to run on a handheld device: Palm, iPhone ...)

Thorkwin

02.16.07 6:47 AM

[...] Maar ben ik er nu? Nee dus, zeker niet omdat Omnifocus van de Omnigroup ook op uitkomen staat en ik met dat bedrijf goede ervaringen heb. [...]

Checklist » Archive » De onbedwingbare

02.17.07 4:27 AM

[...] Omnifocus [...]

Neil Scott – Getting Things Undone

02.17.07 9:55 PM

Does anyone know what Baron Von Snodgrass (above) means when s/he says the following?


“ability to specify whether tasks should be done â??in order givenâ?? or â??in any orderâ?? (which kGTD sorta kinda handles if you add â??*â?? to the project name).”


I've tried to put stars everywhere in kGTD without any effect.

Tobias

02.18.07 6:53 AM

Dashboard integration would be really useful in an app like this, along with seamless integration not just with iCal, but Mail as well.


Is there an approximate shipping date yet? (quarter? year?)

Tim Moss

02.19.07 7:55 AM

Palm synchronization please!

Andrew Petrov

03.14.07 11:11 AM

Release it ASAP, please!!

Taku

03.17.07 2:25 PM

Please make it pssible to asign task to multiple contexts.

Taku

03.19.07 2:37 PM

[...] - I already mentioned that my use of GTD is rendered moot by the prep/grade/prep/grade… revolving door, but as far as GTD tools goes, iGTD looks awfully promising. Until OmniGroup finally comes out with OmniFocus, their long-awaited GTD app that has yet to even reach beta stage, iGTD looks like it could be the grand unification theory that pulls all my wayward GTD stuff together. Haven’t tried it yet but it’s free, and looks good. [...]

Casting Out Nines / Four cool tools

04.03.07 4:21 AM

[...] The Omni Group also has a blog, called The Omni Mouth. From about July 2006 they began to reveal that they were working on a new productivity application, to fit into the GTD6 system. This would replace the free set of scripts, kGTD, which bolted on to OmniOutliner Pro to achieve something similar, albeit in quite a frustrating way.7 At the end of September 2006 they gave it a name, OmniFocus. [...]

Microsoft and the mask of transparency ¶ Arti

05.13.07 10:16 AM

[...] The other case of the “form over function” fetish in mac land arises in discussions comparing iGTD, which actually is out in the wild, with OmniFocus, which is in beta. I’ve used iGTD for a bit and find it a very capable app if you are a member of the GTD cult. What bugs me about these discussions is that, in general, people are waiting with bated breath for OF to come out and are simply putting up with IGTD until that point. There is the minority view that gives iGTD its due and suggests it could possible be better than OF whenever the latter emerges. But this seems to me to border on heretical in the mac community. Omni Group is viewed with much love in general, but this goes way overboard in my view when existing, free, well functioning apps like iGTD are basically dissed in favor of beta-ware. Contrast Merlin Mann’s coverage of the GTD space in mac land. In April we have iGTD at the top of the list in this space. Two months later he is explaining how to move to OF. [...]

In the twinkling of an eye » Mac Intelligent

08.04.07 12:05 PM

[...] Letztens schrieb ich noch, das Actiontastic das Programm meiner Wahl für alles Plandende und zu Erledigende sei, nun, das ist seit geraumer Zeit schon wieder anders und das liegt an iGTD. Das Programm hatte ich mal in irgendeiner frühen Version getestet und hatte einen ganz schlechten Eindruck hinterlassen, war irgendwie sehr buggy und unattraktiv. Jetzt habe ich es nochmal ausprobiert, weil einige Leute voll des Lobes über dieses -unglaublicherweise, Freewareprogramm- waren. Nun, mittlerweile ist Bartek Bargiel, der alleinige Programmierer (was einen gleich Journler assoziieren läßt, ein ähnlich geniales Programm, das ich auch schon vorstellte, und ebenfalls aus der Hand eines einzigen Programmiers stammt) bei Version 1.3.4.3 angekommen und es vergeht kaum ein Tag, an dem iGTD nicht mit eiiner neuen Version am Start ist, die oftmals Dinge einführen die mit anderen Progammen bis heute nicht oder schlecht bis falsch implementiert sind, wie z.B. Mails via Mailtags und F5 in die Inbox holen, was seit neuestem (ca. 3 Tage später) auch mit diversen Browsern funktioniert. Ganz zu schweigen von Smart Foldern, einem ausgefuchsten Quicksilver Plugin und einem für iBackup, funktionierender Syncfunktion, der Option das Programm auf USB-Stick sichern zu können, für Leute die an mehreren Macs arbeitebn und derer feinen Ausgefeiltheiten mehr. Also ich habe meine GTD-Dreamapp gefunden und wüßte nicht was das mit Spannung erwartete Omnifocus noch besser machen könnte. [...]

» Post Topic » iGTD

08.24.07 10:19 AM

[...] P.S. Ð? Ñ?айне Ñ? конеÑ?но надеÑ?Ñ?Ñ?, Ñ?Ñ?о Mailplane бÑ?деÑ? беÑ?плаÑ?ен… Ð?о еÑ?ли авÑ?оÑ? поÑ?Ñ?иÑ?аеÑ?, Ñ?Ñ?о его Ñ?воÑ?ение Ñ?Ñ?оиÑ? денег - а оно иÑ? Ñ?Ñ?оиÑ? - Ñ? Ñ? Ñ?доволÑ?Ñ?Ñ?вием пÑ?иобÑ?еÑ?Ñ? его в Ñ?воÑ? коллекÑ?иÑ? полезнÑ?Ñ? и Ñ?добнÑ?Ñ? Ñ?Ñ?илиÑ?. Ð? Ñ? Ñ?веÑ?ен, Ñ?Ñ?о в компании TextMate, OmniFocus (Ñ?оже беÑ?а - но 100% кÑ?плÑ?), DEVONThink Personal, MailTags 2, NetNewsWire Lite и SecretBook оно займеÑ? доÑ?Ñ?ойное меÑ?Ñ?о. [...]

NilColor » Blog Archive » Mailplane

08.30.07 1:54 AM

[...] system you use to implement GTD? How many of you use apps like Nozbe, iGTD, NextAction, and OmniFocus? How many of you own and use a Moleskine?Comment on this post and let me know you are [...]

What System Do You Use to Get Things Done? at Did

12.17.07 6:17 AM
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.