The Blog

I'm sure glad I'm not on the Omni User Interface team

by Joel on April 27, 2006

You know, after something like 22 years of working on Macintoshes, I have found that I care little about the actual “look” of an application's interface, instead focusing on the “feel”.

This in no way makes me a “touchy-feely” sort of person.

Take, for instance, the current controversy (I like the way some British-English speakers pronounce that word, con-TRAHV-er-sy) surrounding the “under construction” title bar for the latest OmniWeb 5.5 Sneaky Peeks. Quite polarizing, it turns out. Kind of like a Quentin Tarentino movie. Yep, that's it—The OmniWeb 5.5 SP title bar is EXACTLY like a Tarentino movie. Jackie Brown, as a matter of fact.

Anyway, myself, I don't even notice the SP title bar. I, unlike some folks, am able to peer INSIDE the window of pretty much any application,be it an Omni one or no, and direct my focus on the content of said window instead of its framing. I don't know why or how I can do this, perhaps it's due to being from another planet altogether, or that can of spinach I just consumed, but I can do it just the same.

And while I can easily dismiss a series of diagonal stripes from my visual acumen (not to mention red, yellow, and green buttons therein), I would be horribly upset if that for some reason the addition of said stripes were to disable the dragging of a window around on my display, or if it broke double-clicking to minimize to the Dock, or simply displayed the wrong window title completely.

I'm like that. Pretty easygoing so far as the colors/styling quotient lies. Wasn't always this way, I distinctly recall working on the inspector icons for OmniGraffle 4 and getting pretty worked up on getting a good consensus as to what they should look like, what colors to use, etc. Debates such as that one have led to the UI team taking a much more proactive role in application development.

I'm not on that team for good reason: I'm at that point where an application icon is something I poke to switch to an application, nothing more. Of course I'd like it to look all sorts of swell, but in the end I don't even notice it anymore. It's a click target for me to get something done. A title bar is a thingy that has a title in it. A toolbar button has to advertise its function, and little more.

Now, on the other hand, those folks ON the UI team? They have to think about this stuff. Rather constantly, to boot. Not only due to the Omni Group as a whole being pretty vociferous about personal preferences concerning user interface and experience (yours truly excepted only a little bit), but because our users are pretty darn discerning as well.

If they weren't, they wouldn't be using our software, I should think.

Oh, I try to add my feedback, however obliquely, to the UI effort, but in the end it's only a couple of pennies at a time. But really, I'm glad that I'm not on the UI team here at Omni—Not only is it work cut out for them that's horribly involved, we also have the good sense not to include content (as in the opposite of discontent) users of OS X such as myself on such teams, which is what helps considerably in pushing open the envelope of overall user experience with our applications.

 

Comments

I have no problem peering into the core content of a window. However, I have some great peripheral vision. I tend to have an awareness of the entire window, and maybe even more on my screen, seeing all of it as a whole, even as I focus on certain elements.


So, the construction bar was among the first things I noticed when I fired up sp6 yesterday. I tend to notice things that are different from visual expectations, such as seeing a piece of trash in the middle of a desert area.

Ben

04.27.06 9:50 AM

And OmniWeb of all apps in the world is certainly a show of form and function.  Glad you (as a team) think all this thoroughly.

Enrique Garcia

04.27.06 10:14 AM

Pretty sure it's “Tarantino”.

WVH

04.27.06 11:22 AM

I think it was all just a bit of a storm in a teacup, a knee-jerk reaction—after the valid reasons for the stripes were explained I think there's little ground for complaint… and I'm very picky and histrionic about interfaces! :)

marc nothrop

04.27.06 1:15 PM

Jackie Brown rocks.

Chucky

04.27.06 1:52 PM

And we Brits don't say “con-TRAHV-er-sy”; we say “con-TROHV-er-sy”! :D

Mark

04.27.06 4:41 PM

That “con-TRAHV-er-sy” controversy comes probably from Adam Curry (http://www.dailysourcecode.com/) trying to pronounce it in a British way, because you know “he's so European and all”, and failing at it completely now making everyone in the US believe it's pronounced “con-TRAHV-er-sy”, whereas it is not.

Kilian

04.27.06 5:40 PM

Is a few people not liking the stripes really a controversy?


And no Marc, its not a knee-jerk reaction.

Jon Hicks

04.27.06 11:50 PM

That striped bar bothered me so much I hurled all over my keyboard!  Talk about disturbing!


But not really. I only hurl on history books.  Just make sure that it's removed by the final version of OW 5.5.  However, I didn't seem to notice much in the way of new features…I guess it seemed a little snappier, but when you have a 6-year old computer and trying to load up WAY too many pages at the same time, it might always seem somewhat slow.


My favorite difference in American vs. British/Australian sayings is the word “process”.  Americans say the O with an AH sound, where others will use the long O sound…which makes sense since I say procedure with a long O.  So, go figure!


Oh, and my department head (who was British) seemed to add an extra R at the end of the word “idea”. 


That's a good idear….

Chad

04.28.06 2:20 AM

I sit in front of three monitors. Some apps get their own permanent space. When something occurs in one of them, I use my peripheral vision to see it, and then direct my attention to it.


At first I was able to focus on the content of the windows, but when I have three OW windows open side-by-side and other things going on, just the window coming to the foreground with those stripes was distracting.


Many people here have honed their skills to do a job very well. For some that may be design. In that case, they have more awareness as to how an interface affects the user.

Forrest

04.29.06 4:52 AM

Hey, sorry Jon, perhaps you've mistaken my tone? The reaction seemed knee-jerk' to me as the disquiet was mollified once explanations were given; there were things that the people who expressed dislike (or whatever you want to call it) hadn't thought about.


...and anyway, it's inherently a pretty 'soft' issue, I thought there was little tone of irreverence around here?! :)

marc nothrop

04.29.06 8:40 PM

I didn't take your tone as nasty Marc, but I was mollified once Omnigroup added a hidden preference to get rid of the stripes! :D

Jon Hicks

04.30.06 5:49 AM

Thanks for the information, it was very helpful.

care

05.21.06 12:15 PM
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.