The Blog

If only Napoleon had used OmniPlan

by Rowan on January 23, 2007

As I'm sure many readers of this blog are aware, there is this fine fellow named Edward Tufte who is somewhat of a guru in the field of information visualization.  And if you're at all familiar with his work, then you've seen his favorite graphic of all time, the Charles Minard poster of Napoleon's march on Moscow in 1812: 

From Tufte's website, here is his description of this graphic:

Probably the best statistical graphic ever drawn, this map by Charles Joseph Minard portrays the losses suffered by Napoleon's army in the Russian campaign of 1812. Beginning at the Polish-Russian border, the thick band shows the size of the army at each position. The path of Napoleon's retreat from Moscow in the bitterly cold winter is depicted by the dark lower band, which is tied to temperature and time scales.


Well, since I wanted to play around with OmniPlan, I figured I'd recreate this famous graphic.  The result is thusly:

OmniPlan version of Napoleon's march.

OmniPlan Original

Full Size PDF

I took some very liberal liberties in adapting this historical data to OmniPlan, but I think that it turned out pretty well. Mainly, the completion of a task is used to show much of the army is dead.

This was sparked by the conversation on Tufte's website about Project Management Graphics (or Gantt Charts), and specifically by the poster near the bottom who was looking to format his gantt chart, but was running into issues using the program he had. 

Feedback is very welcome, as I'd love to explore new ideas in presenting information using OmniPlan.  I'd also love other data sets to adapt using OmniPlan, so feel free to suggest anything you might think is cool.

 

Comments

I'd like to see visual representations of “confidence” and “uncertainty”. So that bars look different the further out in time they stretch. And resource usage, again dependent on how far out, gives not just a number but a range. Maybe with best/worst case snapshots.


And dependencies - everybody does dependencies between tasks - but there should be a way to show dependencies between *resources*.


Good luck with the improvements!

Damir

01.24.07 10:18 AM

Another thought - a way of visually representing milestones, resources or tasks that - if something goes wrong - have dramatic consequences on the project as a whole.


“If this spec rewrite slips a week the project as a whole slips 4 months.”


“If Jane quits and it takes 8 weeks to get a replacement on board the impact is .... “


Etc.

Damir

01.24.07 10:29 AM

For reference, here’s a detailed view of the original graph. Along with numbers for the army’s size and temperature it also represents the route taken and some of the geography Napoleon’s army encountered.

coconino

01.25.07 8:00 PM

[...] You should probably be familiar with Minard’s famous graph of Napoleon’s doomed Russian campaign, which Edward Tufte calls â??[p]robably the best statistical graphic ever drawn.â?? Well, a blogger at the OmniGroup site has used the OmniPlan software to present Minard’s data as a Gantt chart. I find the juxtaposition of total military failure and massive loss of human life with the bureaucracy and management-related tedium implied by the Gantt chart to be rather amusing, but I must say — with all due respect to the Omni team — that their image falls rather short of â??[p]robably the best statistical graphic ever drawn.â?? [...]

Napoleon and Gantt charts at free variable

01.29.07 6:25 AM

The sorrow! - none of the links are working on the blog (to download Plan files, images etc etc) - can you fix pls!?? :)

Dan

02.01.07 12:46 AM

The links seem to be working for me now. They weren't earlier. 


I think I'm creating an “internet fubar bubble” around me lately, all sorts of crazy issues I've been having.

xmas

02.01.07 9:05 AM
Commenting is not available in this channel entry.